The Ethics of Temperance and Desire

The human experience is a perpetual dance between our innate desires and our aspirations for ethical living. This article explores how temperance, as a cardinal virtue, serves as the crucial mediator in navigating the complex landscape of desire, preventing its descent into vice and guiding us towards a more harmonious and fulfilling existence. Drawing deeply from the wellspring of the Great Books of the Western World, we'll delve into the philosophical underpinnings of this enduring ethical challenge.

The Eternal Struggle Within: Understanding Desire

From the moment we draw breath, we are creatures of desire. We desire food, comfort, companionship, knowledge, recognition, and so much more. This fundamental aspect of our being, while often seen as a driving force for progress and connection, also presents profound ethical dilemmas. Is all desire good? When does it become problematic? And how do we reconcile our powerful urges with the demands of ethics and community?

Ancient philosophers, whose wisdom forms the bedrock of the Great Books, recognized this internal tension. They understood desire (often epithymia in Greek, referring to appetitive desires) not as inherently evil, but as a raw, amoral force that requires careful cultivation and direction. Unchecked, it can lead to chaos; properly guided, it can fuel a life of purpose.

Temperance: A Virtue of Harmonious Living

At the heart of managing desire lies temperance (sophrosyne in Greek), a virtue revered across many philosophical traditions. It's not about abstinence or the eradication of desire, but rather about moderation, self-control, and the rational ordering of our appetites. Temperance ensures that our desires serve our higher good, rather than enslaving us.

Plato's Charioteer Analogy:
In Plato's Phaedrus, he famously illustrates the soul with a charioteer (reason) guiding two winged horses: one noble and spirited (representing thumos, or spiritedness/will), and the other unruly and driven by base appetites (representing epithymia, or desire). Temperance is the skill of the charioteer in reining in the unruly horse, not by destroying it, but by guiding its immense power towards a shared, virtuous destination. It’s about balance and control, not suppression.

Aristotle's Golden Mean:
Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, positions temperance firmly within his doctrine of the Golden Mean. For Aristotle, virtue lies in the middle ground between two extremes, two vices: excess and deficiency. Temperance, then, is the mean concerning pleasures and pains.

  • Excess (Vice): Intemperance or self-indulgence, where one pursues pleasure without restraint, leading to degradation and harm.
  • Deficiency (Vice): Insensibility or asceticism, where one is unduly indifferent to natural and healthy pleasures, which can also be a distortion of a full human life.

The temperate person, according to Aristotle, enjoys pleasures appropriately, neither too much nor too little, and is guided by reason in doing so. This doesn't mean a life devoid of enjoyment, but one where enjoyment is rightly placed and proportioned.

(Image: A classical Greek fresco depicting a serene figure, possibly a goddess or philosopher, gently holding the reins of two horses – one spirited and rearing, the other calm and controlled – symbolizing reason's mastery over the soul's desires, with a backdrop of a tranquil garden.)

Desire: Not Inherently Vicious, But Potentially So

It's crucial to distinguish between desire itself and the ethical implications of how we respond to desire. Natural desires for food, shelter, and companionship are essential for survival and flourishing. The problem arises when these desires become disordered, excessive, or directed towards inappropriate objects.

Consider the spectrum:

Aspect of Desire Temperance in Action Intemperance (Vice)
Food & Drink Eating to nourish the body, enjoying flavors in moderation Gluttony, excessive consumption, binge eating/drinking
Wealth & Possessions Seeking enough for comfort and security, generosity Greed, avarice, obsession with material accumulation
Physical Pleasure Enjoying intimacy within healthy relationships Promiscuity, lust, exploitation of others for pleasure
Recognition & Esteem Striving for excellence, accepting deserved praise Vanity, hubris, seeking fame at any cost, envy
Leisure & Relaxation Restoring oneself for renewed effort Sloth, excessive idleness, avoidance of responsibility

This table illustrates how the same underlying desire, when untempered, can swiftly transform into a vice that harms the individual and society.

The Interplay of Virtue and Vice

Temperance is rarely an isolated virtue. It works in concert with others. Prudence (practical wisdom) helps us discern the right course of action regarding our desires. Courage enables us to resist temptation when our desires pull us towards the wrong path. Justice ensures that our pursuit of personal desires does not infringe upon the rights or well-being of others.

Conversely, a lack of temperance often begets other vices. An intemperate pursuit of pleasure can lead to deceit, irresponsibility, and a neglect of duties. It can erode character, diminish one's capacity for rational thought, and ultimately undermine one's freedom, as one becomes a slave to their impulses.

Modern Reflections on Ancient Wisdom

While the language may differ, the ethical challenge of managing desire remains profoundly relevant today. In a consumer-driven society often characterized by instant gratification, the ancient call for temperance resonates with renewed urgency. From digital addiction to environmental overconsumption, the lessons gleaned from the Great Books of the Western World offer a timeless framework for understanding and addressing the ethical dimensions of our desires. Cultivating temperance isn't about denying our humanity, but about elevating it, allowing us to live more intentionally, responsibly, and ultimately, more freely.

Conclusion: Cultivating a Balanced Self

The ethics of temperance and desire is a cornerstone of classical philosophy, offering profound insights into human nature and the path to flourishing. By understanding desire not as an enemy to be vanquished, but as a powerful force to be wisely guided, we can cultivate the virtue of temperance. This enables us to avoid the pitfalls of vice, fostering a balanced self that lives in harmony with reason, community, and the pursuit of genuine well-being. The journey towards temperance is an ongoing one, an eternal practice of self-awareness and rational self-governance that continues to shape our ethical landscape.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Plato's Chariot Allegory Explained""

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Temperance""

Share this post