The Measured Life: An Ethical Exploration of Temperance and Desire

This article delves into the profound ethics surrounding temperance and desire, exploring how classical philosophy, particularly from the Great Books of the Western World, frames these concepts. We will examine how managing our desires through the virtue of temperance is crucial for human flourishing, distinguishing it from the vice of intemperance and the pitfalls of unchecked appetites. Understanding this ancient wisdom provides a timeless framework for navigating the complexities of our inner lives.

The Eternal Dance: Desire and the Human Condition

From the moment we draw breath, we are creatures of desire. We crave sustenance, comfort, knowledge, connection, and myriad other things. These desires, in their raw form, are neither inherently good nor bad; they are simply part of our nature. However, it is how we engage with and manage these desires that forms the bedrock of our ethics and shapes our character.

Ancient philosophers, whose works form the backbone of the Great Books of the Western World, spent considerable time dissecting the nature of desire. Plato, in his Republic, famously illustrates the soul with a charioteer (reason) guiding two horses: one noble (spirit/thumos) and one unruly (appetite/epithumia). The appetitive horse represents our base, bodily desires – hunger, thirst, sexual urges, and the pursuit of material wealth. For Plato, an unbridled appetitive soul leads to internal chaos and a life dominated by fleeting pleasures, hindering the pursuit of true wisdom and justice.

Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, also addresses desire (orexis) as a fundamental human faculty. He distinguishes between rational and irrational desires, recognizing that while some desires are natural and necessary for survival, others can be cultivated and refined. The challenge, for both Plato and Aristotle, lies not in eliminating desire, which is impossible and undesirable, but in ordering it correctly.

Temperance: The Virtue of Self-Mastery

This is where temperance (Greek: sophrosyne) enters the philosophical stage as a cardinal virtue. Often misunderstood as mere abstinence or repression, temperance is far more nuanced. It is the virtue of moderation, self-control, and the harmonious ordering of our desires under the guidance of reason.

Defining Temperance

  • Not Suppression, but Harmony: Temperance doesn't demand the eradication of desire. Instead, it advocates for a balanced relationship with our appetites, ensuring they serve our higher goals rather than enslaving us.
  • Rational Control: It is the faculty by which reason asserts its rightful place as the guide of our passions and appetites.
  • Internal Order: As Plato describes, a temperate individual possesses an inner harmony, where all parts of the soul agree on who should rule – reason.
  • The Golden Mean: Aristotle positions temperance as the "golden mean" between two extremes. It is the appropriate disposition towards pleasures and pains, finding the right amount, at the right time, for the right reasons.

(Image: A classical allegorical painting depicting a serene female figure of Temperance, dressed in flowing, modest robes, gently pouring water from one ornate vessel into another, symbolizing moderation and the measured flow of life's pleasures. She stands composed, eyes downcast in thoughtful contemplation, amidst a vibrant background where figures representing various human desires – perhaps a lavish banquet with revelers on one side and a solitary scholar engrossed in books on the other – are subtly visible in the distance, emphasizing her role in balancing the extremes of indulgence and asceticism. The scene is bathed in soft, natural light, highlighting the timeless wisdom of her calm demeanor.)

The Ethical Imperative: Why Temperance Matters

The pursuit of temperance is not merely about personal discipline; it's a profound ethical imperative. For the ancient Greeks, living a good life – a flourishing life, or eudaimonia – was inextricably linked to the cultivation of virtue.

  • For Individual Flourishing: An individual lacking temperance is prone to excess, making poor choices driven by immediate gratification rather than long-term well-being. Such a person cannot truly be free, being a slave to their impulses. Temperance allows for self-mastery, enabling us to pursue what is truly good for us, leading to a more stable and fulfilling life.
  • For Social Harmony: A society composed of intemperate individuals would be chaotic, driven by selfishness and unchecked appetites. Temperance, by fostering self-control and consideration, contributes to a more just and harmonious community.
  • Foundation for Other Virtues: Temperance is often considered a foundational virtue, as it creates the internal conditions necessary for the development of other virtues like courage, justice, and wisdom. Without the ability to control one's impulses, how can one act courageously in the face of fear, or justly when tempted by self-interest?

Virtue and Vice: The Spectrum of Desire

Understanding temperance is best achieved by contrasting it with its corresponding vices. Aristotle's framework of the golden mean is particularly useful here, illustrating how every virtue exists as a midpoint between two extremes of vice: an excess and a deficiency.

Aspect of Life Vice of Deficiency Virtue (The Mean) Vice of Excess
Desire for Bodily Pleasures (Food, Drink, Sex) Insensibility (Apathy, lack of proper enjoyment) Temperance (Moderation, self-control, appropriate enjoyment) Intemperance (Licentiousness, gluttony, hedonism, unchecked craving)
Control over Appetites Passivity (Unable to resist temptation) Self-Mastery (Reason guiding desires) Compulsion (Driven by obsessive desires)
Approach to Life's Enjoyments Austerity (Denial of all pleasure) Balanced Enjoyment (Appreciation without attachment) Indulgence (Excessive pursuit of pleasure)

The intemperate person is enslaved by their desires, constantly seeking more, never satisfied. The insensible person, on the other hand, denies themselves even appropriate and healthy pleasures, which can also be a form of imbalance. Temperance strikes the perfect balance, allowing for the enjoyment of life's goods without being consumed by them.

While the ancients spoke of charioteers and appetitive souls, the core challenge remains the same in our contemporary world. We are bombarded by stimuli designed to ignite and satisfy our desires – consumerism, instant gratification through technology, and the constant pursuit of external validation. The ethics of temperance offers a powerful antidote to these modern pressures.

By reflecting on the wisdom contained within the Great Books of the Western World, we are reminded that true freedom comes not from limitless indulgence, but from the disciplined cultivation of our inner lives. To be temperate is to be truly free, to be the master of oneself, and to live a life guided by reason and purpose, rather than by the whims of fleeting desire.

YouTube Video Suggestions:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Plato Republic Chariot Allegory Temperance"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Temperance Virtue Explained"

Share this post