The Ethical Tug-of-War: Navigating Temperance and Desire

Summary: In the grand tapestry of human experience, few threads are as intricately woven as our desires and the ethical imperative to temper them. This article delves into how philosophers, from ancient Greece to the medieval era, explored Temperance as a cardinal virtue—a rational mastery over desire that steers us away from vice and towards a flourishing ethical life, drawing insights from the Great Books of the Western World. We'll explore how this delicate balance shapes our character and determines the quality of our existence.

Hey everyone, Chloe here! Let's talk about something that's been on my mind, something profoundly human and utterly timeless: the push and pull of our desires and the beautiful, often challenging, art of temperance. It's not just some old-school concept; it's a living, breathing challenge that shapes our everyday choices and, ultimately, our very character. The Great Books of the Western World are absolutely brimming with wisdom on this very topic, offering a rich lineage of thought on how we navigate the powerful currents of what we want versus what is good.

Understanding Desire: The Engine of Our Being

At its core, desire is a fundamental aspect of human existence. It's the yearning for pleasure, comfort, knowledge, connection, or even just the next bite of chocolate. It propels us forward, motivates our actions, and fuels our ambitions. But here's the rub: unchecked, unexamined desire can also lead us astray, plunging us into excess and ultimately, unhappiness.

Philosophers throughout history have grappled with the nature of desire:

  • Plato saw desire as part of the "appetitive" soul, a wild horse needing guidance from reason.
  • Epicurus distinguished between natural and necessary desires (like hunger, thirst), natural but unnecessary desires (gourmet food), and unnatural and unnecessary desires (fame, wealth), suggesting that only the first category truly leads to contentment.
  • Christian theologians often viewed desire, especially carnal desire (concupiscence), as a consequence of the Fall, requiring spiritual discipline.

The point isn't that desire itself is inherently bad; it's how we relate to it, how we manage its intensity and direction, that determines its ethical impact.

Temperance: The Art of Self-Mastery

This is where temperance steps onto the stage. Often translated as moderation, self-control, or sobriety (sophrosyne in Greek), temperance is not about denying all pleasure or eradicating all desire. Instead, it's about finding the right measure, the appropriate balance. It's the virtue that allows reason to guide our appetites, ensuring they serve our overall well-being rather than dictating our every move.

Consider it like a skilled musician tuning an instrument:

  • Too tight, and the string breaks (excessive repression, leading to a brittle spirit).
  • Too loose, and it produces a dull sound (uncontrolled desire, leading to chaos).
  • Just right, and it creates harmony (temperance, leading to a flourishing life).

(Image: An ancient Greek fresco depicting a charioteer, representing Reason, skillfully guiding two horses—one spirited (Spirit) and one unruly (Appetite or Desire)—along a difficult path, symbolizing the soul's journey towards virtue and the mastery of passions.)

Philosophical Perspectives on Temperance and Desire

The concept of temperance is a cornerstone of ethics in many philosophical traditions. Here's a quick tour through some giants from the Great Books:

  • Plato (c. 428–348 BCE), The Republic: For Plato, temperance is the harmony of the soul, where the rational part rules, the spirited part supports it, and the appetitive part obeys. It's not just an individual virtue but also a characteristic of a just society. When each part of the soul performs its proper function without overstepping, the soul is temperate and just.

  • Aristotle (384–322 BCE), Nicomachean Ethics: Aristotle places temperance squarely within his doctrine of the Golden Mean. It's the mean between the vice of insensibility (a deficiency of pleasure-seeking) and the vice of self-indulgence (an excess). A temperate person enjoys pleasures appropriately, neither too much nor too little, guided by reason. He distinguishes temperance from continence; the temperate person desires what is good and moderate, while the continent person desires excess but resists it through willpower.

  • The Stoics (e.g., Seneca, Epictetus, Marcus Aurelius): While not using "temperance" in precisely the same way as Plato or Aristotle, the Stoics placed immense value on controlling one's passions and desires. They advocated for apatheia—not apathy, but freedom from irrational passions and emotional disturbance. This involved understanding what is within our control (our judgments, actions) and what is not (external events, other people's desires), and focusing our efforts accordingly.

  • Augustine of Hippo (354–430 CE), Confessions: Augustine grappled profoundly with the nature of desire, particularly carnal desire, in the context of Christian theology. He saw temperance as a crucial virtue for reorienting one's desires away from earthly pleasures and towards God. His journey is a powerful testament to the struggle and ultimate triumph of spiritual temperance.

  • Thomas Aquinas (1225–1274 CE), Summa Theologica: Integrating Aristotelian philosophy with Christian doctrine, Aquinas reaffirmed temperance as a cardinal virtue. He saw it as restraining the concupiscible appetite (the desire for sensible pleasures) and regulating our use of created goods, ensuring they serve our ultimate end, which is union with God.

The Spectrum: Virtue and Vice

The pursuit of temperance is an ethical journey, a constant negotiation between our inner urges and our rational judgment.

Virtues Associated with Temperance:

  • Prudence: Guiding our choices with practical wisdom.
  • Self-Control: The ability to resist immediate gratification for long-term good.
  • Patience: Enduring delay or provocation without undue agitation.
  • Humility: Understanding our limits and avoiding arrogance.
  • Modesty: Appropriate behavior regarding appearance and conduct.

Vices Opposed to Temperance:

  • Gluttony: Excessive indulgence in food and drink.
  • Lust: Uncontrolled sexual desire.
  • Greed/Avarice: Excessive desire for wealth or material possessions.
  • Sloth/Acedia: Apathy or spiritual laziness, a lack of desire for good.
  • Profligacy/Extravagance: Reckless wastefulness, an excess in spending or living.

The challenge lies in finding the mean—not just avoiding obvious excesses, but also ensuring we don't fall into the deficiency of being too detached or unresponsive to appropriate pleasures. A truly temperate person experiences joy and pleasure, but always in due measure and at the right time.

Why Does This Matter Today?

In an age of instant gratification, endless consumerism, and digital distractions, the ethics of temperance and desire are more relevant than ever. Learning to pause, to reflect, and to choose deliberately rather than reacting impulsively to every urge is a superpower. It leads to greater freedom, deeper relationships, and a more meaningful existence. It's about living a life of intention, not merely reaction.

So, as we navigate our bustling lives, let's remember the timeless wisdom of the Great Books. Let's cultivate that inner charioteer, guiding our desires with reason and striving for that harmonious balance that temperance offers.

YouTube Video Suggestions:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Temperance Golden Mean""
2. ## 📹 Related Video: PLATO ON: The Allegory of the Cave

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Plato Chariot Allegory Soul Explained""

Share this post