The Ethics of The Ethics of Desire

The Ethics of Desire: Navigating the Labyrinth of Human Aspiration

Summary: Human desire is a fundamental, often tempestuous, force driving our actions and shaping our lives. From the primal urge for survival to the loftiest intellectual aspirations, desire fuels our existence. Yet, its inherent power raises profound ethical questions: How do we distinguish between desires that lead to good and those that lead to evil? What role does our will play in directing or restraining these powerful urges? This article delves into the rich philosophical tradition, drawing from the Great Books of the Western World, to explore the complex ethics of desire, examining how thinkers across millennia have grappled with its moral implications.

The Inescapable Urge: Defining Desire in Philosophical Thought

At its core, desire is an inclination or longing for something. It is the engine of human striving, the impulse that moves us from a state of deficiency towards a perceived fulfillment. Philosophers have long recognized its centrality, but have diverged significantly on its nature and its ethical standing. Is desire inherently disruptive, something to be overcome, or is it a natural, even necessary, component of a flourishing life?

The answers to these questions are not simple, reflecting the intricate tapestry of human experience and moral reasoning. Understanding the ethics of desire requires us to consider not just what we want, but why we want it, and what the consequences of fulfilling that want might be.

Historical Perspectives on Desire and its Ethical Dimensions

Across the span of Western thought, the concept of desire has been a battleground for moral inquiry. From ancient Greece to the Enlightenment and beyond, philosophers have sought to map its terrain and understand its relationship to human will and the pursuit of good and evil.

Plato's Tripartite Soul: In works like The Republic, Plato posits a soul divided into three parts: the appetitive (desires for food, sex, wealth), the spirited (desires for honor, recognition), and the rational (desires for truth, knowledge). For Plato, ethical living means the rational part, guided by the Form of the Good, must govern the lower desires, ensuring harmony and justice within the individual soul. Unchecked appetitive desires lead to tyranny of the soul and, by extension, society.
Aristotle's Virtuous Mean: Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, viewed desire as a natural capacity. The key was not to eliminate desire, but to cultivate it through reason and habituation into virtuous dispositions. Ethical desire is one that aims at the good (eudaimonia, or human flourishing) and is moderated by the "golden mean." For instance, courage is a virtuous mean between the excess of recklessness and the deficiency of cowardice, both driven by misguided desires.
Augustine's Love and Will: For St. Augustine, particularly in Confessions, desire is inextricably linked to love. The ethical question becomes: what do we love or desire? If our ultimate desire is directed towards God, it leads to salvation and true good. If our desires are primarily for worldly pleasures and temporal goods, it leads to sin and evil, stemming from a disordered will corrupted by original sin.
Aquinas and Natural Law: St. Thomas Aquinas, building on Aristotle and Augustine, saw human desire as oriented towards specific natural goods (life, procreation, knowledge, society). Through reason, we can discern these natural inclinations and formulate moral laws. Ethical desire aligns with these natural laws, guided by right reason, while desires that deviate from this path are considered evil.
Kant's Duty vs. Inclination: Immanuel Kant, in his Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals, presented a radical departure. For Kant, true moral action cannot be based on desire or inclination, no matter how benevolent. Morality must be derived from pure reason, acting out of a sense of duty to the universal moral law (the Categorical Imperative). Desires, being contingent and subjective, cannot be the foundation for objective ethics.
Nietzsche's Will to Power: Friedrich Nietzsche, challenging traditional morality, viewed desire as a manifestation of the "Will to Power" – an intrinsic drive to grow, overcome, and affirm life. For Nietzsche, good and evil are often constructs that serve to suppress strong, life-affirming desires. The ethical challenge is to re-evaluate values and embrace desires that lead to self-overcoming and the creation of new values, rather than succumbing to herd morality.

Image: (Image: A classical Greek sculpture depicting a figure in contemplation, perhaps Plato or Aristotle, with one hand gesturing towards the sky and the other towards the earth, symbolizing the tension between ideal forms/reason and earthly desires/experience. The figure's expression is serious, reflecting deep thought on the nature of human striving and moral choice.)

The Interplay of Desire and Will: Agency and Choice

Central to the ethics of desire is the concept of the will. Is the will merely a slave to our strongest desires, or does it possess the autonomy to choose which desires to pursue, which to resist, and which to cultivate?

Many philosophers contend that true moral agency lies in the will's capacity to direct or even shape our desires. It is through our will that we can:

Discern: Evaluate the nature and potential consequences of a desire.
Prioritize: Rank desires according to a moral framework or long-term goals.
Restrain: Choose not to act on desires deemed unethical or detrimental.
Cultivate: Actively foster desires for knowledge, virtue, or the good of others.

Without the faculty of will, ethical deliberation about desire would be moot. We would be mere automatons, driven by instinct. The challenge, therefore, is to train the will to align with reason and moral principles, transforming raw desire into purposeful action.

Desire, Good, and Evil: The Moral Compass

The ethical significance of desire becomes most apparent when we consider its outcomes. When does desire lead to good, and when does it precipitate evil?

Aspect of Desire	Path Towards Good	Path Towards Evil
Object	Desire for wisdom, justice, compassion, beauty, truth.	Desire for power over others, revenge, material excess.
Intention	To benefit oneself and others, to uphold moral law.	To harm, exploit, or disregard moral duties.
Control	Governed by reason, moderated by the will.	Unchecked, impulsive, tyrannical over the will.
Consequence	Leads to personal flourishing, societal harmony.	Leads to suffering, injustice, moral degradation.

It is rarely the mere existence of a desire that is deemed evil, but rather the will's choice to act upon it in a way that violates moral principles, harms others, or degrades the self. Conversely, desires directed towards genuine good, when pursued with wisdom and temperance, are often celebrated as the very essence of virtuous living.

Cultivating Ethical Desire: A Philosophical Endeavor

Given the profound impact of desire on our moral lives, how can we cultivate desires that lead to good? Philosophers offer various pathways:

Education and Habituation (Aristotle): Through repeated virtuous actions, we can train ourselves to desire the right things in the right measure.
Rational Reflection (Plato, Kant): Regularly subjecting our desires to the scrutiny of reason, asking whether they align with universal principles or the highest good.
Spiritual Discipline (Augustine): Directing our deepest longings towards a transcendent good or divine purpose.
Self-Knowledge (Socrates): Understanding the true nature of our desires and their potential effects on ourselves and the world.
Empathy and Compassion (Various): Cultivating desires that prioritize the well-being of others, fostering a sense of shared humanity.

The journey of ethical desire is not about extinguishing all longing, but about refining it, purifying it, and directing it towards ends that elevate rather than diminish us. It is an ongoing process of self-examination and moral growth.

Conclusion: The Enduring Challenge of Desire

The ethics of desire remains one of philosophy's most enduring and vital inquiries. From the ancient Greeks who sought harmony in the soul to modern thinkers who grapple with existential drives, the question of how we manage our deepest longings continues to define our understanding of good and evil, will, and human flourishing. By engaging with the wisdom of the Great Books, we gain not only a deeper appreciation for the complexity of desire but also invaluable tools for navigating its powerful currents, striving always to direct our aspirations towards a life of virtue and meaning.

YouTube: "Plato's Theory of Desire" or "Kant's Ethics of Duty vs. Desire"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "The Ethics of Desire philosophy"