The Ethical Duty of Temperance: A Cornerstone of the Well-Ordered Soul

Summary: In an age often characterized by excess and instant gratification, the ancient virtue of temperance stands as an enduring beacon, not merely as a quaint ideal, but as a profound ethical duty. This article explores temperance as more than simple abstinence, revealing its true nature as the rational governance of desires and appetites, essential for individual flourishing and societal harmony. Drawing from the profound insights of the Great Books of the Western World, we shall uncover why cultivating temperance is not merely advisable, but an imperative for anyone seeking a truly good and meaningful existence, safeguarding against the corrosive effects of vice.

The Enduring Call to Self-Mastery: An Introduction to Temperance

From the Stoic philosopher's quiet contemplation to the bustling agora of ancient Athens, the concept of temperance has resonated through the annals of Western thought as a cardinal virtue. It is a theme woven intricately into the fabric of the Great Books, a recurring challenge posed to humanity: to master oneself before attempting to master the world. Yet, in our modern discourse, temperance is often misunderstood, conflated with asceticism or prudishness. To truly grasp its significance, we must strip away these contemporary misconceptions and return to its philosophical roots, recognizing it not merely as a personal preference, but as an ethical duty.

The ancients, observing the inherent human struggle between reason and desire, understood that an unbridled soul was a chaotic one, prone to vice and incapable of true happiness or justice. For them, temperance was the very mechanism by which reason asserted its rightful dominion, bringing order to the internal polis of the individual.

Defining Temperance: Beyond Mere Abstinence

To speak of temperance is not to advocate for a life devoid of pleasure, but rather a life in which pleasure is understood, appreciated, and experienced within the bounds of reason and human flourishing. As elucidated by thinkers like Plato in his Republic and Aristotle in his Nicomachean Ethics, temperance (or sophrosyne in Greek) is the harmonious integration of the soul's desires with its rational faculty.

Key Aspects of Temperance:

  • Rational Governance: It is the exercise of reason over the appetitive part of the soul, ensuring that desires for food, drink, sex, and material possessions do not overwhelm judgment.
  • The Golden Mean: Aristotle famously described virtues as a mean between two extremes of vice. Temperance is the mean between intemperance (excess) and insensibility (deficiency). It is not about feeling nothing, but feeling the right amount, at the right time, for the right reasons.
  • Inner Harmony: Plato saw temperance as the agreement between the superior and inferior parts of the soul, a kind of internal self-control where reason persuades appetite to obey. This internal order is the bedrock of external justice and personal integrity.
  • Self-Knowledge: To be temperate requires a deep understanding of one's own desires, triggers, and limitations. It is an ongoing process of self-assessment and adjustment.

It is crucial to differentiate temperance from its vices. A person is not temperate simply by abstaining from all pleasure, for that might indicate insensibility or an unhealthy repression. Rather, a temperate person knows how to enjoy pleasures in moderation, without being enslaved by them, and can forgo them when reason dictates.

The Ethical Imperative: Why Temperance is a Duty

Why elevate temperance from a commendable trait to an ethical duty? The answer lies in its foundational role for both individual and collective well-being.

  1. For Individual Flourishing (Eudaimonia):

    • Freedom: An intemperate person is a slave to their desires. Duty to temperance liberates the individual from this servitude, allowing for true autonomy and self-determination.
    • Rationality: Unchecked passions cloud judgment, leading to poor decisions and regret. Temperance preserves the clarity of reason, enabling one to pursue higher goods and lead a thoughtful life.
    • Health and Well-being: Excessive indulgence in any appetite invariably leads to physical, mental, and spiritual decay. Temperance is a duty to one's own health and longevity.

  2. For Societal Harmony and Justice:

    • Reliability: A temperate individual is more reliable, trustworthy, and consistent in their actions. They are less prone to impulsive behaviors that can harm others or break commitments.
    • Justice: As Thomas Aquinas, drawing heavily from Aristotle, articulated in his Summa Theologica, temperance is one of the four cardinal virtues, essential for a just society. An intemperate populace, driven by insatiable desires, is prone to conflict, exploitation, and the erosion of common good.
    • Good Governance: Both Plato and Aristotle argued that a state composed of temperate citizens is more stable and just. Leaders, in particular, have an ethical duty to temperance, as their personal discipline directly impacts the commonweal.

The duty of temperance, therefore, is not a burden but a pathway to genuine human excellence. It is the active cultivation of an inner state that allows one to live fully, responsibly, and in accordance with one's highest rational nature.

The Spectrum of Vice: Intemperance and Insensibility

Understanding temperance is illuminated by examining its opposing vices. As Aristotle meticulously detailed, virtue resides in the mean, flanked by extremes.

| Virtue/Vice Spectrum | Description | Consequences

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "The Ethical Duty of Temperance philosophy"

Share this post