The Ethical Duty of Temperance and Ethical

The Ethical Imperative of Temperance: A Montgomery Reflection

In an age often characterized by excess and instant gratification, the ancient concept of temperance might seem an anachronism, a relic of a bygone era. Yet, upon closer philosophical inspection, it reveals itself not merely as a quaint suggestion for personal improvement, but as a profound ethical duty — a cornerstone of individual flourishing and societal well-being. This article posits that temperance, far from being a mere preference for moderation, is a critical virtue whose cultivation is incumbent upon all who seek a truly good life, demanding a conscious mastery over our appetites and passions to avoid the pitfalls of vice.

Understanding Temperance: More Than Mere Abstinence

Temperance, or sophrosyne in the Greek tradition, is frequently misunderstood. It is not asceticism, nor is it the joyless denial of pleasure. Rather, as articulated by the titans of the Great Books of the Western World, it is the reasoned control over our natural desires and inclinations. It is the judicious application of moderation, ensuring that our pursuit of pleasure — be it through food, drink, wealth, or sensual experience — remains within bounds dictated by reason and conducive to our overall well-being.

The ethical duty of temperance arises from its instrumental role in achieving a harmonious existence. Without it, our rational faculty, which distinguishes us as human beings, becomes enslaved to our baser instincts.

Key Aspects of Temperance:

Self-Mastery: The ability to govern one's own impulses and appetites.
Rational Control: Subordinating desires to the dictates of reason.
Harmonious Living: Fostering internal peace and external balance.
The Mean: As Aristotle taught, temperance is the virtuous mean between deficiency (insensitivity) and excess (intemperance).

The Duty to Ourselves and Others

Why is temperance an ethical duty rather than a personal choice? The answer lies in its profound impact, both individually and collectively.

1. Duty to Self:
Intemperance, the vice of excess, corrodes the individual from within. It impairs judgment, diminishes physical and mental health, and ultimately undermines true freedom. A person enslaved by their desires is not truly free, but rather a puppet to external stimuli or internal urges. Plato, in his Republic, illustrates how an intemperate soul is a disordered soul, incapable of achieving inner harmony or justice. The duty to temperance, therefore, is a duty to preserve one's own rational capacity, health, and dignity.

2. Duty to Society:
The ripples of individual intemperance extend far beyond the self. A society populated by intemperate individuals is prone to instability, injustice, and discord. Reckless consumption, unchecked ambition, and unbridled passions can lead to economic collapse, social unrest, and moral decay. Conversely, a citizenry that cultivates temperance contributes to civic order, responsible governance, and mutual respect. The ethical duty to temperance thus becomes a social responsibility, a commitment to the common good.

(Image: A classical Greek sculpture depicting a serene, contemplative figure, perhaps a philosopher, with one hand gently resting on their chest, conveying self-possession and inner calm amidst flowing drapery and classical architectural elements in the background, symbolizing the integration of reason and emotion.)

Virtue vs. Vice: The Spectrum of Human Conduct

The philosophical tradition, particularly that found in the Great Books, consistently frames temperance within the broader discussion of virtue and vice.

Virtue: Temperance	Vice: Deficiency (Insensitivity)	Vice: Excess (Intemperance)
Rational control over desires	Indifference to legitimate pleasures	Slavery to desires; uncontrolled pursuit of pleasure
Leads to inner harmony and peace	Can lead to a stunted experience of life	Leads to disorder, regret, and self-destruction
Fosters physical and mental well-being	Might miss out on wholesome aspects of human experience	Damages health, relationships, and reputation
Enables pursuit of higher goods and intellectual life	Lacks appreciation for the richness of human existence	Distracts from and undermines higher pursuits
Contributes to societal stability and justice	May lack the impetus for engagement	Contributes to societal discord and injustice

Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, meticulously details how virtue lies in the "golden mean" between two extremes of vice. Temperance is precisely this mean concerning pleasures and pains, particularly those relating to touch and taste. To be temperate is to feel pleasure and pain at the right time, in the right way, and towards the right objects.

Echoes from the Great Books

The concept of temperance resonates throughout the foundational texts of Western thought:

Plato: In the Republic, temperance is presented as a crucial virtue for both the individual and the state. It is the agreement between the superior and inferior parts of the soul as to which should rule, bringing harmony to the soul's three elements: reason, spirit, and appetite.
Aristotle: For Aristotle, temperance is one of the cardinal moral virtues, developed through habituation. It is a disposition to choose the mean in matters of pleasure, particularly those of the body. He contrasts it sharply with intemperance, which he considers a grave vice that corrupts character.
The Stoics: Philosophers like Seneca and Epictetus championed self-control and moderation as essential for living in accordance with nature and achieving tranquility (ataraxia). Their emphasis on controlling what is within our power — our judgments and desires — directly aligns with the ethical duty of temperance.
Thomas Aquinas: Integrating classical thought with Christian theology, Aquinas classified temperance as one of the four cardinal virtues. For him, it moderates the concupiscible appetites (desires for sensible goods) according to reason, aligning human action with divine law.

Cultivating the Virtue in a Modern World

The ethical duty of temperance is perhaps more challenging, yet more vital, in our contemporary landscape. The incessant barrage of advertising, the normalization of excess, and the instant gratification offered by technology all conspire against the cultivation of this essential virtue. Yet, the call to temperance remains. It is a call to conscious living, to deliberate choice, and to the profound recognition that true freedom lies not in the unbridled pursuit of every whim, but in the rational mastery of one's inner world. By embracing temperance, we fulfill an ancient duty that promises not only personal peace but also a more just and flourishing society.

YouTube Video Suggestions:

📹 Related Video: ARISTOTLE ON: The Nicomachean Ethics

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Temperance Virtue""
2. ## 📹 Related Video: PLATO ON: The Allegory of the Cave