The Eclectic (Marxist) Dialectic?

This responsion to Christopher Hitchens's, "materialist" claim is countered in the question, which asks whether or not the material parts of history borrow from Marxism?

Latest Post Careful where you step, it's a slippery slope by Heraclitus public

The Eclectic (Marxist) Dialectic?

I think the materialist conception of history is valid.

- Christopher Hitchens (1949-2011)

devil holding heart mural
The Devil is in the Details - Another planksip Möbius

The Devil is in the Details

The Eclectic (Marxist) Dialectic?

Inspired by Christopher Hitchens's (1949-2011) quote, "I think the materialist conception of history is valid.". The titled responsion is...

Christopher Hitchens - planksip
Christopher Eric Hitchens was an Anglo-American author, columnist, essayist, orator, religious and literary critic, social critic, and journalist.
What do Christopher Hitchens and Omar Khayyam have in common? Find out on planksip.

Dialectical materialism is often confused with historical materialism. However, they are not the same thing. Dialectical materialism is a non-dogmatic, but at the same time, revolutionary theory of nature, consciousness, and society. It can be easily explained through dialectical thinking in that the process of dialectic is an interaction of two different types of thinking, one a dialectical materialist and the other is dialectical thinking or dialectical argumentative.

Dialectical materialism is actually the theory of scientific socialism. It is in fact not a theory, it is the only thing that can be used as the basis of political action and development for the working class. Dialectical materialism can be defined as an explanation of the reality of human action in relation to nature. In other words, it is a science that is very much related to philosophy, but at the same time, it is also very close to science, because both philosophy and science can be described through dialectical thinking.

Dialectical materialism was developed in the 1920s by Karl Marx. He also formulated three main ideas related to this theory. He wrote the following thesis;

The first thing that dialectical materialism explains is that the development of human beings, society, and culture is determined by the development of the economic base of human life. Therefore, if you analyze any social order, whether communist, syndicalist, trade union, landlords, etc, you will find that its structure is developed in relation to the structure of the economy of a specific place. In other words, the structure of human society is based on the structure of the economic base of the society.

The second thing that dialectical materialism explains is that the structure of any system of production is related to the mode of the production of the material in that particular system. Therefore, any change in the mode of production will have an impact on the structure of that system. This also leads to the conclusion that the dialectical materialist theory is the only scientific truth. It is also the only truth in all of science because all forms of the natural sciences are based on dialectical thinking.

The third part of dialectical materialism is that it shows that the nature of any object or situation can be changed by the actions of human beings without any external intervention. It also shows that these changes are related to the internal development of the dialectics of the system of production.

Dialectical materialism has been criticized on many counts. The most common criticism is that it is a revolutionary theory, which is not accepted by classical economics. Another criticism is that it does not offer a complete explanation for the structure of the human system or the development of the system of production in relation to the environment.

Many people have said that this theory does not fit into the theory of political economy. However, this critique is unfounded.

devil holding heart mural
The Devil is in the Details - Another planksip Möbius

The planksip writer's cooperative is sponsoring a re-writing of this article (500 words) with $500 CAD in prize money for the best article as voted by your peers in the planksip writer's cooperative. Judged by your peers, your chance to join a community of creative thinkers and win over $750,000 CAD in prize money is your entry point into becoming a planksip journalist.

We want to change the way people engage. The planksip organic platform is dedicated to supporting your voice as a writer and a thought leader. Join today, membership matters!

Joining the planksip Writer’s Cooperative
The planksip writers cooperative gives members writing assignments, of which they compete for cash prizes. This article highlights the benefits of membership as well as outlines the rules and guidelines for submissions. Becoming a planksip writer is easier than you think.
Christopher Hitchens

Published 10 months ago