A Fundamental Summary

The distinction between virtue and vice lies at the very heart of moral philosophy, offering a framework for understanding human character and conduct. Simply put, virtues are commendable traits of character, dispositions towards the Good, often cultivated through habit and reason, leading to human flourishing. Vices, conversely, are undesirable character traits, inclinations towards Evil, which detract from a well-lived life and often cause harm. This fundamental definition, explored extensively in the Great Books of the Western World, is not merely an academic exercise but a practical guide for ethical living, helping us discern paths that lead to excellence from those that lead to moral degradation.

The Philosophical Bedrock: Understanding Virtue

From the ancient Greeks to medieval scholastics and beyond, philosophers have grappled with the definition of virtue. It's more than just doing good deeds; it's about being a certain kind of person.

What is Virtue?
Virtue (from the Latin virtus, meaning excellence or manliness) refers to a moral excellence, a disposition to act in a morally good way. It's a stable, admirable trait of character that enables an individual to think, feel, and act well. As Aristotle meticulously laid out in his Nicomachean Ethics, a cornerstone of the Great Books, virtues are often found as a "golden mean" between two extremes of vice—one of excess and one of deficiency.

Consider these key aspects of virtue:

  • Habitual Disposition: Virtues are not innate but cultivated through practice and repetition. One becomes courageous by repeatedly acting courageously.
  • Rational Choice: Virtuous actions are performed knowingly, deliberately, and for their own sake, not out of compulsion or for external reward.
  • Aimed at the Good: The ultimate goal of virtuous living is eudaimonia, or human flourishing—a life well-lived, full of purpose and meaning.

Examples of Virtues:

  • Courage: The mean between rashness (excess) and cowardice (deficiency).
  • Temperance: The mean between indulgence (excess) and insensibility (deficiency).
  • Justice: Often considered a cardinal virtue, ensuring fairness and rights.
  • Wisdom: Practical insight into how to live well.

The Shadow Side: Defining Vice

If virtue guides us towards the Good, then vice pulls us towards Evil. Understanding vice is crucial for appreciating the full scope of the distinction.

What is Vice?
Vice (from the Latin vitium, meaning a defect or blemish) is a moral failing, a habit or disposition that is morally wrong or bad. It represents a character flaw that hinders human flourishing and often leads to harmful outcomes, both for the individual and for society. Where virtue represents the peak of human potential, vice embodies its corruption.

Key characteristics of vice include:

  • Habitual Tendency: Like virtues, vices are often developed through repeated actions, forming ingrained patterns of undesirable behavior.
  • Irrational or Misguided Choice: Vicious acts stem from a lack of proper reasoning, uncontrolled passions, or a mistaken understanding of what constitutes the Good.
  • Detrimental to Well-being: Vices diminish the individual's character and often lead to suffering, regret, and a life lacking true fulfillment.

Examples of Vices:

  • Cowardice: A deficiency of courage.
  • Gluttony/Greed: Excesses related to appetite and desire for material possessions.
  • Envy: Resentment aroused by another's possessions or qualities.
  • Sloth: A spiritual or intellectual laziness.

The Crucial Distinction: Virtue vs. Vice

The distinction between virtue and vice is not merely about labeling actions as "good" or "bad." It's about recognizing the fundamental divergence in character formation and its profound impact on life's trajectory. This distinction is a cornerstone of ethical reasoning found throughout the Great Books, from Plato's dialogues to Aquinas's Summa Theologica.

Feature Virtue Vice
Nature Moral excellence, good habit Moral failing, bad habit
Direction Towards the Good, flourishing Towards Evil, degradation
Origin Cultivated through reason and practice Cultivated through irrationality and indulgence
Impact Enhances character, promotes well-being Diminishes character, causes harm
Aristotelian The "golden mean" between two extremes An extreme (excess or deficiency)
Purpose To achieve eudaimonia (human flourishing) To satisfy base desires or avoid discomfort

Understanding this table helps illuminate why ancient philosophers placed such emphasis on character development. It’s about building a life of substance and meaning, rather than succumbing to impulses that lead to regret.

(Image: A classical Greek fresco depicting allegorical figures of "Arete" (Virtue) and "Kakia" (Vice) at a crossroads, with Arete pointing towards a steep, arduous path leading to a sunlit temple on a mountain, and Kakia gesturing towards a wide, easy road descending into a shadowed valley, symbolizing the choices between a difficult, virtuous life and an easy, vicious one.)

The Pursuit of Good and the Avoidance of Evil

The ultimate significance of the distinction between virtue and vice lies in its practical application: guiding humanity in the pursuit of the Good and the avoidance of Evil. Philosophers like Immanuel Kant, though approaching ethics from a different angle, still underscored the importance of moral duty and good will, which align with virtuous principles. To strive for virtue is to consciously choose a path of moral development, recognizing that true freedom often lies in self-mastery and adherence to ethical principles.

Conversely, ignoring the reality of vice leaves one vulnerable to its insidious influence. It is through understanding the nature of evil—not as an abstract force, but as a product of human choices and character flaws—that we can actively resist it. The wisdom gleaned from the Great Books consistently reminds us that our character is not predetermined; it is forged through the continuous choices we make between virtuous action and vicious indulgence.

Ultimately, the enduring relevance of this distinction is that it empowers us to critically examine our own lives, our habits, and our aspirations. It calls us to reflect on the kind of person we wish to be and the kind of world we wish to build, guided by principles that have resonated across millennia.

YouTube Suggestions:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Virtue Ethics Explained"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Plato Cardinal Virtues Explained Ancient Philosophy"

Share this post