The Everlasting Distinction Between Virtue and Vice

The pursuit of a meaningful life often hinges on our capacity to discern between actions and character traits that uplift us and those that diminish us. This article explores the fundamental distinction between virtue and vice, delving into their definition, philosophical origins, and practical implications for navigating the landscape of Good and Evil. Understanding this crucial divide, as illuminated by the thinkers of the Great Books of the Western World, is not merely an academic exercise but a foundational step towards ethical living and human flourishing.

Defining the Moral Compass: Virtue and Vice

At its core, the distinction between virtue and vice lies in their fundamental orientation towards what is considered "good" or "bad" for human beings and society.

  • Virtue: A virtue (from Latin virtus, meaning "excellence" or "manliness") is typically defined as a moral excellence, a disposition of character that disposes one to act in an excellent manner. It is a stable and positive trait, often developed through habit and reason, leading to actions that are morally right and beneficial. Philosophers like Aristotle saw virtue as a "mean" between two extremes, a balance achieved through practical wisdom.
  • Vice: A vice, conversely, is a moral failing or a bad habit. It is a disposition of character that disposes one to act in a morally wrong or harmful manner. Vices are often characterized by excess or deficiency, representing a deviation from the balanced, virtuous path. Where virtue builds character and fosters Good, vice erodes it and propagates Evil.

The definition of these terms is not static across all philosophical traditions, yet a common thread persists: virtues are qualities that enable human beings to thrive, while vices impede this flourishing.

Philosophical Roots: Insights from the Great Books

The Great Books of the Western World offer an unparalleled exploration of virtue and vice, shaping our understanding for millennia.

Plato's Ideal Forms and the Soul

In Plato's philosophy, particularly in works like The Republic, virtues are seen as reflections of ideal Forms, with the ultimate Form being the Good. For Plato, a virtuous soul is one where reason governs the spirited and appetitive parts, leading to the cardinal virtues:

  • Wisdom (Sophia): The virtue of the rational part of the soul, guiding the other parts.
  • Courage (Andria): The virtue of the spirited part, enabling one to face fear appropriately.
  • Temperance (Sophrosyne): The virtue of the appetitive part, controlling desires and pleasures.
  • Justice (Dikaiosyne): The overarching virtue, ensuring harmony and balance among all parts of the soul and in society.

Vices, in this framework, represent a disharmony, where the lower parts of the soul usurp the role of reason, leading to imbalance and moral corruption.

Aristotle's Ethics of Character

Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, provides perhaps the most influential account of virtue as a cultivated character trait. He argues that virtues are not innate but acquired through habituation. His famous doctrine of the "Golden Mean" posits that virtue lies between two vicious extremes:
(Image: An ancient Greek bust of Aristotle, with a thoughtful expression, superimposed over a scroll displaying excerpts from the Nicomachean Ethics, emphasizing the concept of the 'Golden Mean' with a balanced scale icon.)

Virtue (Mean) Vice of Deficiency Vice of Excess
Courage Cowardice Rashness
Temperance Insensibility Self-indulgence
Generosity Stinginess Prodigality
Proper Pride Humility (false) Vanity
Wittiness Boorishness Buffoonery

Aristotle emphasizes that finding the mean is not a mathematical calculation but requires practical wisdom (phronesis), which allows one to judge what is appropriate in a given situation. Vices are deviations from this mean, either by having too little or too much of a particular quality.

Medieval Christian Thought: Augustine and Aquinas

Christian philosophers like St. Augustine and St. Thomas Aquinas integrated classical virtues with theological virtues (faith, hope, charity). For them, virtues are dispositions that align human will with divine will, leading towards ultimate beatitude. Vices, particularly the "Seven Deadly Sins," are seen as disordered loves or attachments that turn the soul away from God, representing a profound Evil.

  • Augustine: Emphasized love as the root of all virtues and disordered love as the root of all vices.
  • Aquinas: Systematized virtues and vices, detailing how each vice is a departure from the rational good, often through a failure to properly order one's appetites and passions.

The Practical Distinction: Navigating Good and Evil

The distinction between virtue and vice is not confined to philosophical texts; it is a lived reality. Recognizing this distinction allows us to:

  1. Evaluate Character: We can assess our own character and the character of others, understanding what drives actions towards Good or Evil.
  2. Guide Moral Action: Virtues provide a framework for ethical decision-making, encouraging actions that are courageous, just, and temperate. Vices serve as warning signs, indicating paths to avoid.
  3. Foster Personal Growth: By identifying our own vices, we can actively work to cultivate corresponding virtues, transforming our habits and dispositions.
  4. Build Better Communities: Societies that value and promote virtues tend to be more harmonious and just, while those riddled with vice suffer from discord and corruption.

Understanding the definition of virtue and vice arms us with the conceptual tools to critically examine human behavior and strive for ethical excellence. It reminds us that while the path to virtue is often challenging, it is the most rewarding journey towards a life well-lived.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Virtue Ethics Summary""

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Plato's Republic: Cardinal Virtues Explained""

Share this post