The Enduring Question: What is the Definition of a Citizen?

The concept of a citizen is one of the most fundamental yet persistently debated ideas in political philosophy. Far from a simple legal designation, the definition of a citizen delves into the very essence of belonging, participation, and the intricate relationship between an individual and the State. It is a concept that has evolved dramatically across millennia, shaped by different forms of governance, societal values, and the prevailing Law of the land. This pillar page will explore the multifaceted definition of a citizen, tracing its philosophical journey from ancient poleis to modern nation-states, drawing insights from the profound thinkers whose works are enshrined in the Great Books of the Western World.

Unpacking the Core Concept: What Exactly Is a Citizen?

At its heart, a citizen is an individual recognized by a State or nation as a member, implying a reciprocal relationship of rights and duties. However, this seemingly straightforward statement belies a profound complexity. To truly grasp the definition, we must look beyond mere residency or birthplace.

Beyond Simple Residency: The Nuance of Belonging

While residing within a State's borders is often a prerequisite, it does not, in itself, constitute citizenship. The true nuance lies in the active or potential relationship with the governing body, the shared responsibilities, and the protective framework of the Law. It's about being an integral part of the political community, not merely an inhabitant.

The Etymology of "Citizen" and "State"

The very words we use hint at their deep historical roots. "Citizen" comes from the Latin civitas, referring to the city or community, and civis, an inhabitant of that city. Similarly, "State" derives from status, indicating a standing or condition, evolving to denote a political body. These linguistic origins underscore the ancient connection between the individual and their organized community.

Ancient Foundations: Citizenship in the Classical World

To understand the modern definition of a citizen, we must first journey back to the classical world, where the very idea of political participation was forged.

Aristotle's Definition: The Participating Member of the Polis

Perhaps no philosopher laid a more foundational stone for the definition of a citizen than Aristotle. In his seminal work, Politics (a cornerstone of the Great Books collection), he famously declared that a citizen is one "who shares in the administration of justice and in the holding of office."

  • Active Participation: For Aristotle, citizenship was not passive. It demanded direct involvement in the deliberation and decision-making of the polis (city-state).
  • Capacity for Rule and Being Ruled: A true citizen possessed the capacity to both govern and be governed, understanding the Law and contributing to its formation and enforcement.
  • Exclusions: Crucially, Aristotle's definition was highly restrictive. Slaves, women, resident aliens (metics), and manual laborers were explicitly excluded, as they were not deemed to possess the leisure or capacity for political life.

This Greek model emphasized intensive, direct participation, making citizenship a demanding but highly privileged status.

Roman Citizenship: Rights, Privileges, and Empire

The Roman concept of civitas offered a different, yet equally influential, definition. While the Greeks focused on direct participation, Roman citizenship, especially as the Republic expanded into an Empire, became more about legal status, rights, and privileges under Roman Law.

  • Legal Status: Roman citizenship conferred specific legal protections, the right to own property, the right to marry Roman citizens, and, eventually, the right to vote (though often impractical for those far from Rome).
  • Expansion: Unlike the exclusive Greek model, Roman citizenship was gradually extended to various peoples across the Empire, often as a tool of integration and control. This expansion, however, diluted the direct participatory aspect of citizenship.
  • Duties: Alongside rights came duties, including military service and tax obligations, all enforced by the formidable framework of Roman Law.
Feature Ancient Greek (e.g., Athens) Ancient Roman (Republic/Empire)
Core Idea Active participation in governance Legal status, rights, and privileges
Primary Duty Deliberation, justice, office-holding Military service, obedience to Law
Exclusions Women, slaves, foreigners, manual laborers Slaves, initially many non-Romans
Scope Limited to the polis Expanded across a vast Empire

The Medieval Interlude and the Rise of the Sovereign State

The fall of Rome ushered in a period where the classical definition of a citizen largely faded. Allegiance shifted from the abstract State to concrete lords and monarchs in a feudal system. Individuals were subjects, bound by fealty and custom, rather than citizens endowed with explicit rights derived from a shared political compact.

From Subjects to Citizens: A Shifting Paradigm

The slow erosion of feudalism and the emergence of centralized monarchies eventually paved the way for the modern nation-state. This transition began to reintroduce the idea of a universal relationship between the individual and the sovereign power, laying the groundwork for a renewed philosophical inquiry into the definition of a citizen.

The Enlightenment and the Social Contract: Redefining the Citizen

The Enlightenment period, with its emphasis on reason, individual rights, and the nature of legitimate government, profoundly reshaped the definition of a citizen. Philosophers of the social contract tradition, whose works dominate the Great Books, grappled with how individuals consent to be governed and what rights and duties such consent entails.

John Locke, in his Two Treatises of Government, posited that individuals possess inherent natural rights (life, liberty, property) that pre-exist the State. For Locke, the definition of a citizen is tied to their consent to form a government to protect these rights.

  • Limited Government: Citizens agree to a government with limited powers, retaining certain unalienable rights.
  • Right of Revolution: If the government oversteps its bounds and infringes upon natural rights, citizens have the right to resist and establish a new one.
  • Rule of Law: Citizenship implies living under a system of established, impartial Law that applies equally to all.

Rousseau and the General Will: Active Participation in the Sovereign

Jean-Jacques Rousseau, in The Social Contract, offered a more radical definition of a citizen, one deeply rooted in collective self-governance. For Rousseau, true liberty comes from obeying a Law that one has prescribed for oneself as part of the collective sovereign.

  • Active Law-Making: Citizens are not merely subjects but active participants in the general will, collectively creating the Law that governs them.
  • Moral Freedom: To be a citizen is to be morally free, as one obeys oneself through the collective.
  • Obligation to the Community: The definition implies a strong civic virtue and an unwavering commitment to the common good of the State.

Hobbes and the Sovereign's Authority: Order Above All

Thomas Hobbes, in Leviathan, presented a starkly different perspective. While also a social contract theorist, Hobbes argued that individuals, in their natural state, live in a "war of all against all." To escape this, they cede nearly all their rights to an absolute sovereign, creating the State.

  • Security over Liberty: The definition of a citizen under Hobbes is primarily one of a subject who owes absolute obedience to the sovereign in exchange for peace and order.
  • No Right of Rebellion: Once the contract is made, citizens have no right to rebel, as doing so would plunge society back into chaos.
  • Law as Sovereign's Command: The Law is simply the will of the sovereign, and the citizen's duty is to follow it.

(Image: An elaborate 17th-century engraving depicting a majestic, crowned figure composed of countless tiny human bodies, holding a sword and a sceptre, towering over a peaceful landscape with a walled city. This iconic representation of Hobbes's Leviathan symbolizes the collective power and authority of the sovereign State, to which individual citizens surrender their rights for order and security.)

Modern Interpretations: Citizenship in the Contemporary World

Today, the definition of a citizen continues to evolve, incorporating legal frameworks, social expectations, and global challenges.

In most modern nation-states, citizenship is primarily a legal status conferred by Law. This can occur through:

  • Jus Soli (Law of the Soil): Citizenship by birth within the State's territory.
  • Jus Sanguinis (Law of the Blood): Citizenship by descent from a citizen parent, regardless of birthplace.
  • Naturalization: A legal process by which a non-citizen acquires citizenship, often requiring residency, language proficiency, and an oath of allegiance.

This legal definition brings with it a bundle of rights (e.g., voting, diplomatic protection, access to public services) and duties (e.g., taxes, military service, obedience to Law).

Active vs. Passive Citizenship: Beyond the Ballot Box

Beyond the legal definition, there's a growing emphasis on the active dimension of citizenship.

  • Passive Citizenship: Fulfilling legal requirements like voting and paying taxes.
  • Active Citizenship: Engaging in civic life through volunteering, community activism, informed debate, and holding elected officials accountable. This echoes Aristotle's call for participation but on a broader scale.

The concept of "global citizenship" also emerges, suggesting a responsibility towards humanity and the planet, transcending national borders, even if not a formal legal definition.

The Evolving Definition: Challenges and Debates

The contemporary world presents new challenges to the traditional definition of a citizen:

  • Statelessness: Individuals not recognized as citizens by any State, often due to conflict, discrimination, or legal loopholes.
  • Dual Citizenship: Holding citizenship in two or more states, raising questions of primary allegiance.
  • Digital Citizenship: The rights and responsibilities of individuals in the digital realm, including online privacy, security, and ethical behavior.

Why Does the Definition of a Citizen Matter?

Understanding the definition of a citizen is not merely an academic exercise; it has profound implications for individuals, societies, and the very fabric of governance.

Foundation of Rights and Responsibilities

The definition dictates who is entitled to fundamental rights (freedom of speech, due process, voting) and who bears the responsibilities (taxes, military service, civic engagement) that uphold the State and its Law. Without a clear definition, these foundations crumble.

Shaping the State and Society

How a State defines its citizens profoundly influences its character. An inclusive definition can foster diverse, participatory societies, while an exclusive one can lead to marginalization and conflict. The relationship between the citizen and the Law is the bedrock of societal order.

Personal Identity and Belonging

For individuals, citizenship provides a crucial sense of identity, belonging, and security. It connects them to a shared history, culture, and political destiny, offering a framework within which to live their lives.

Conclusion

The definition of a citizen is a rich tapestry woven from history, philosophy, and the ever-evolving realities of human society. From Aristotle's vision of the active participant in the polis to the modern legal frameworks of the nation-state, the core inquiry remains: What does it mean to belong, to participate, and to be recognized within a political community under the rule of Law?

The Great Books of the Western World offer an indispensable guide to this question, revealing that the definition is not static but a dynamic concept, constantly being negotiated and redefined. As we navigate an increasingly interconnected world, understanding these foundational philosophical debates becomes ever more crucial for shaping just and equitable societies.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Aristotle's Politics: Citizenship and the Ideal State Explained"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Social Contract Theory: Crash Course Philosophy #33 - Locke, Rousseau, Hobbes"

Share this post