The Enduring Enigma: Unpacking the Definition of a Citizen

The definition of a citizen is not merely a legal formality but a profound philosophical question that has evolved dramatically throughout history, shaping our understanding of the individual's relationship to the State and Law. From the exclusive participatory ideals of ancient Greece to the complex rights and responsibilities of modern nation-states, the concept of citizenship is a dynamic tapestry woven from political theory, societal values, and the ever-changing fabric of human governance. This pillar page delves into the multifaceted interpretations of citizenship, drawing insights from the foundational texts of Western thought to illuminate its enduring significance.

I. The Ancient Roots: Citizenry in Classical Thought

The earliest, and perhaps most influential, philosophical explorations of citizenship emerged in the city-states of ancient Greece. Here, the definition of a citizen was inextricably linked to active participation in public life, a concept far removed from many contemporary understandings.

A. Aristotle's Polis and the Active Citizen

For Aristotle, as explored in his Politics (a cornerstone of the Great Books of the Western World), a citizen was not simply an inhabitant of a city, nor someone who merely enjoyed legal rights. Instead, he famously posited that a citizen is "one who shares in the administration of justice and in the holding of office." This implied:

  • Active Participation: Citizens were expected to participate directly in the assembly, serve on juries, and hold magistracies.
  • Self-Sufficiency (Autarky): The polis aimed for self-sufficiency, and citizens contributed to this collective goal.
  • Moral Virtue: True citizenship required a certain level of moral and intellectual virtue, enabling sound judgment in public affairs.
  • Exclusivity: This definition was inherently exclusive. Slaves, women, resident aliens (metics), and children were explicitly excluded from citizenship, as they were not deemed capable of, or permitted, active political life. Their roles, while essential to the State, did not grant them the status of citizen.

B. Plato's Ideal State and the Role of the Guardian

Plato, in his Republic, conceived of an ideal State where individuals were assigned roles based on their natural aptitudes. While he didn't use the term "citizen" in the same participatory sense as Aristotle, his framework defined an individual's relationship to the polis through their specific function. The "Guardians" (philosopher-kings and soldiers) bore the heaviest burden of the State's welfare, demonstrating a different form of civic duty, one less about universal participation and more about specialized contribution to the common good.

Key Characteristics of Ancient Citizenship:

  • Participation-Centric: Emphasis on direct involvement in governance.
  • Exclusive: Limited to a select group (freeborn men of property).
  • Duty-Bound: Primary focus on obligations to the polis.
  • Local Identity: Deeply tied to the specific city-state.

II. The Evolving Landscape: From Subject to Sovereign

The fall of the Roman Empire and the rise of feudalism dramatically altered the concept of belonging, shifting from the participatory citizen to the loyal subject. However, the Enlightenment period reignited the philosophical debate, laying the groundwork for modern citizenship.

A. The Medieval Interlude and Feudal Allegiance

During the Middle Ages, the relationship between individuals and power was primarily one of subject to lord or king. Loyalty was personal and hierarchical, rooted in oaths of fealty and land tenure. The idea of a universal Law governing all equally, or of individual rights inherent to a "citizen," was largely absent. Belonging was defined by one's place within a social hierarchy, not by active political participation in a State.

B. The Dawn of Modernity: Hobbes, Locke, and the Social Contract

The 17th and 18th centuries witnessed a profound shift, with philosophers grappling with the origins of political authority and the nature of individual rights. The concept of the "social contract" became central to redefining the individual's relationship to the State.

  • Thomas Hobbes (Leviathan): Argued that individuals, in their natural State, surrender some freedoms to an absolute sovereign for the sake of order and protection from chaos. The "subject" gains security in exchange for obedience to the Law.
  • John Locke (Two Treatises of Government): Proposed a more liberal view, suggesting that individuals possess natural rights (life, liberty, property) that pre-exist the State. Government's legitimacy derives from the consent of the governed, and its primary purpose is to protect these rights. Here, the individual begins to emerge as a rights-bearing entity, moving closer to the modern definition of a citizen.

Jean-Jacques Rousseau, in The Social Contract (another pillar of the Great Books), further advanced the notion of popular sovereignty. He argued that true freedom lies in individuals collectively creating the Law to which they are subject. For Rousseau, the citizen is both the subject of the Law and the co-creator of it, participating in the "general will." This concept laid the groundwork for modern democratic ideals where citizens are not merely subjects but active participants in their own governance.

(Image: A detailed depiction of Rousseau presenting his ideas on the social contract to a group of engaged, diverse citizens in a neoclassical setting, emphasizing intellectual discourse and the birth of modern civic thought.)

III. The Modern Conundrum: Rights, Responsibilities, and the Globalized State

Today, the definition of a citizen is complex, encompassing legal status, political rights, social responsibilities, and a sense of belonging to a national State.

  • Legal Citizenship (De Jure): This is the most common understanding. It refers to the formal status granted by a State according to its Law. This typically involves:
    • Jus Soli (Law of the soil): Citizenship by birth within a territory.
    • Jus Sanguinis (Law of the blood): Citizenship by descent from a citizen parent.
    • Naturalization: The process by which a non-citizen acquires citizenship.
  • Philosophical Citizenship: This delves deeper into the moral and ethical implications of belonging. It explores what it means to be a citizen beyond legal documents – encompassing civic virtue, engagement, and a commitment to the common good.

B. Rights and Privileges: What Does it Mean to Be a Citizen Today?

Modern citizenship comes with a bundle of rights and privileges, often enshrined in constitutional Law:

  • Political Rights: The right to vote, to hold public office, to freedom of speech and assembly.
  • Civil Rights: Protection under the Law, freedom from arbitrary detention, due process.
  • Social Rights: Access to education, healthcare, social security (though the extent varies by State).
  • Protection: Diplomatic protection abroad, security within national borders.

C. Duties and Obligations: The Citizen's Role in the State

Alongside rights, citizens bear significant duties to the State:

  • Obeying the Law: A fundamental obligation for the functioning of society.
  • Paying Taxes: Contributing to the public services provided by the State.
  • Civic Engagement: Voting, volunteering, community participation.
  • National Service: In some states, military service or other forms of national duty.

Ancient vs. Modern Citizenship: A Comparative Glance

Feature Ancient Citizenship (e.g., Athenian) Modern Citizenship (e.g., Democratic Nation-State)
Primary Focus Active political participation and duty to the polis Rights (civil, political, social) and responsibilities to the State
Inclusion Highly exclusive (freeborn men, landowners) Broadly inclusive (birthright, naturalization, universal suffrage)
Relationship Direct, personal involvement in governance Often representative; mediated through institutions and Law
Identity Strongly tied to the local city-state Primarily tied to the nation-state, with growing global awareness
Source of Law Custom, tradition, decrees of the assembly and courts Constitutional Law, statutes, international treaties

IV. Beyond Borders: Challenges to the Traditional Definition

The 21st century presents new challenges to the traditional definition of a citizen, pushing us to consider identities that transcend national boundaries.

A. Statelessness and Dual Citizenship

  • Statelessness: Individuals who are not recognized as citizens by any State. This highlights the critical importance of legal citizenship for basic human rights and protection.
  • Dual Citizenship: Individuals holding citizenship in two or more states. This complicates traditional notions of singular allegiance and national identity, raising questions about conflicting loyalties and obligations.

B. Global Citizenship and Cosmopolitanism

Emerging concepts like "global citizenship" suggest an identity rooted in shared humanity and responsibility towards the planet, transcending national borders. Cosmopolitanism, a philosophical stance, advocates for a universal moral community, where individuals see themselves as citizens of the world, upholding universal human rights and justice. While not a legal definition, it challenges us to broaden our understanding of civic duty beyond the confines of the nation-State.

V. An Ongoing Philosophical Inquiry

The definition of a citizen remains a vibrant and essential area of philosophical inquiry. From the ancient Greek polis to the modern globalized world, the concept has continuously adapted, reflecting changing power structures, ethical considerations, and the evolving relationship between the individual, the State, and the Law. Understanding this evolution is crucial, for how we define a citizen ultimately shapes the kind of society we aspire to build – one that balances rights with responsibilities, individual freedoms with collective well-being, and local identity with a sense of global humanity.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Aristotle Politics Citizenship Explained""

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Social Contract Theory: Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau""

Share this post