The Definition of a Citizen: A Philosophical Journey Through Our Place in the Polis

What does it truly mean to be a citizen? At first glance, the definition seems straightforward: a legal member of a State. Yet, beneath this surface lies a rich, complex tapestry woven from history, philosophy, and political theory. From the ancient Greek polis to the modern nation-state, the concept of a citizen has continuously evolved, challenging us to reconsider our relationship with the State and the Law, and our fundamental role within society. This pillar page delves into the multifaceted definition of a citizen, exploring its historical shifts, philosophical underpinnings, and contemporary relevance.

The Evolving Tapestry of Citizenship: From Polis to Nation-State

The journey to understand the modern definition of a citizen is a long one, rooted deeply in the annals of Western thought. It's a concept that has been reshaped by wars, revolutions, and the shifting sands of political power.

Ancient Roots: The Greek Polis and Roman Civitas

The earliest profound explorations of citizenship emerge from ancient Greece. For philosophers like Aristotle, a citizen was not merely a resident but an active participant in the governance of the polis (city-state). This was a highly exclusive club, typically reserved for freeborn men who owned property, excluding women, slaves, and foreigners. The definition here was intrinsically tied to civic duty and the ability to share in ruling and being ruled, making decisions under the prevailing Law.

The Roman Empire later expanded this notion with the concept of civitas. While initially exclusive, Roman citizenship eventually extended to various peoples across the empire, albeit with different grades and privileges. It was a legal status that conferred specific rights and protections under Roman Law, a powerful tool for integration and control by the State.

Medieval Allegiances and the Rise of the Nation-State

During the medieval period, the concept of citizenship as we understand it largely receded. Allegiance was primarily to a feudal lord, a monarch, or the Church, rather than to an abstract State. Rights and duties were more about subjecthood than citizenship.

The Enlightenment and the subsequent rise of the nation-state in the 17th and 18th centuries fundamentally reshaped the definition. Revolutions in America and France championed the idea of popular sovereignty, asserting that political authority derived from the people, not divine right. Here, the citizen emerged as the primary unit of the State, endowed with inherent rights and bound by a social contract to obey the Law.

Philosophical Lenses: Great Thinkers on the Citizen

The "Great Books of the Western World" offer invaluable insights into how humanity's most profound thinkers have grappled with the definition of a citizen.

The Ancients: Aristotle and the Active Polis Member

Aristotle, in his Politics, famously asserted that a citizen is "one who shares in the administration of justice and in the holding of office." For him, the essence of citizenship lay in active political participation and the capacity to contribute to the common good of the polis. This definition emphasized engagement, virtue, and the pursuit of a flourishing life within a community governed by just Law. He differentiated between a citizen and a mere inhabitant, highlighting that being a citizen required more than just residence; it demanded involvement.

The Social Contract Theorists: Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau

The Enlightenment era introduced the powerful concept of the social contract, profoundly influencing the definition of a citizen.

  • Thomas Hobbes (in Leviathan) viewed citizens as individuals who, in exchange for security and order, surrender some natural liberties to an absolute sovereign State. The Law is the command of this sovereign, and the citizen's duty is obedience.
  • John Locke (in Two Treatises of Government) posited that individuals enter into a social contract to protect their natural rights (life, liberty, property). The citizen consents to be governed by a State whose power is limited by Law, and has the right to resist tyranny.
  • Jean-Jacques Rousseau (in The Social Contract) presented the citizen as a participant in the general will, actively creating the Law that governs them. For Rousseau, true freedom lies in obeying a Law one has prescribed for oneself, making the citizen both subject and sovereign.

Modern Perspectives: From Kant to Arendt

Later philosophers continued to refine the definition. Immanuel Kant saw the citizen as a co-legislator, participating in the creation of universal Law based on reason. Hannah Arendt, drawing from the Greek tradition, emphasized the importance of the public sphere and political action for the realization of human freedom, viewing citizenship as the right to have rights and to act in concert with others.

(Image: A detailed illustration depicting an allegorical scene of the social contract. In the foreground, figures representing diverse individuals from different walks of life are shown in various postures of agreement and discussion, some signing a symbolic scroll. Behind them, a grand, classical building representing the "State" stands firm, with a balanced scale of justice prominently displayed. Rays of light emanating from the building illuminate the individuals, symbolizing the enlightenment and order brought by the agreement. The background shows a bustling city, suggesting the society that benefits from this foundational pact.)

The definition of a citizen today often encompasses two distinct, yet intertwined, dimensions: the legal and the moral.

From a strictly legal standpoint, citizenship is a formal relationship between an individual and a State, governed by its Law. This status grants certain rights and imposes specific duties.

Common Legal Criteria for Citizenship:

  • Jus Soli (Right of Soil): Citizenship acquired by birth within the territory of a State, regardless of the nationality of the parents.
  • Jus Sanguinis (Right of Blood): Citizenship acquired by birth from a parent who is a citizen of that State, regardless of the place of birth.
  • Naturalization: The process by which a non-citizen voluntarily becomes a citizen of a State, usually involving residency requirements, language proficiency, and an oath of allegiance to the Law and State.
  • Marriage: In some cases, marriage to a citizen can facilitate the naturalization process.

This legal definition determines who belongs to the State and who is subject to its jurisdiction and protection under its Law.

Beyond Legality: The Moral Dimension

However, being a citizen is often understood as more than just a legal status. It carries a moral weight, implying a set of virtues, responsibilities, and an active commitment to the well-being of the community and the integrity of the State. This moral dimension echoes the ancient Greek emphasis on civic virtue.

  • Civic Engagement: Participating in public life, voting, volunteering.
  • Respect for Law: Upholding the legal framework of the State.
  • Social Responsibility: Contributing to the common good, caring for fellow citizens.
  • Critical Thinking: Engaging thoughtfully with political issues and holding the State accountable.

Rights and Responsibilities: The Citizen's Covenant

The relationship between a citizen and the State is often seen as a covenant, a mutual agreement where rights are granted in exchange for responsibilities. This reciprocal relationship forms the bedrock of modern democratic societies.

Fundamental Rights of a Citizen

The rights typically afforded to citizens are diverse and vary between states, but generally include:

  • Political Rights: The right to vote, to hold public office, to participate in political parties, and to free speech regarding political matters.
  • Civil Rights: The right to due process, freedom of religion, freedom of assembly, protection from discrimination, and the right to a fair trial under the Law.
  • Social and Economic Rights: The right to education, healthcare, social security, and safe working conditions (though the extent of these can vary widely).

Essential Responsibilities of a Citizen

These rights are balanced by crucial responsibilities that uphold the functioning of the State and society:

  • Obeying the Law: Adhering to the legal framework established by the State.
  • Paying Taxes: Contributing to the funding of public services and governmental functions.
  • Civic Participation: Voting, engaging in public discourse, and potentially serving on juries or in the military.
  • Defending the State: In times of national crisis, a citizen may have a duty to defend the State.
  • Respecting Others' Rights: Recognizing and upholding the rights of fellow citizens.

Challenges and Contradictions in the Definition

Despite its foundational importance, the definition of a citizen is not without its challenges and contradictions in the contemporary world.

  • Statelessness: Millions worldwide lack citizenship in any State, rendering them without legal protection or fundamental rights, highlighting the power of the State to define inclusion and exclusion.
  • Dual Citizenship: The increasing prevalence of individuals holding citizenship in multiple states complicates traditional notions of singular allegiance and national identity.
  • Global Citizenship: The idea of "global citizenship" challenges the primacy of the nation-state, suggesting a broader identity and responsibility towards humanity, transcending national Law and borders. This concept often sparks debate about whether one can truly be a citizen without a corresponding global State.
  • Erosion of Rights: Even within established states, the rights of citizens can be challenged or curtailed, raising questions about the enduring strength of the social contract and the role of the Law in protecting individuals.

Conclusion: Re-evaluating Our Place in the Polis

The definition of a citizen is far more than a mere legal formality; it is a dynamic concept, continuously shaped by philosophical inquiry, historical context, and the evolving relationship between individuals and the State. From Aristotle's active participant to the social contract theorists' rights-bearing individual, and to modern debates about global identity, the core questions remain: What are our obligations to the community? How do we ensure justice under the Law? And what does it truly mean to belong?

As we navigate an increasingly interconnected world, understanding the nuances of citizenship encourages us to reflect on our own roles, responsibilities, and the profound power of collective action in shaping the societies we inhabit. It's a call to engage, to question, and to contribute to the ongoing definition of what it means to be a citizen in our shared State.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Aristotle Politics Citizenship Explained"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Social Contract Theory Hobbes Locke Rousseau Explained"

Share this post