The Elusive Definition of a Citizen: A Philosophical Journey

The concept of a citizen is one we often take for granted, yet its definition has been a battleground of ideas for millennia. From the city-states of ancient Greece to the complex global societies of today, understanding what it means to be a citizen is fundamental to grasping our relationship with the State and the Law. This pillar page delves into the rich philosophical history of citizenship, tracing its evolution through the minds of some of the greatest thinkers, revealing how this core concept is perpetually redefined by societal structures, political theory, and the enduring quest for justice.

Unpacking the Definition: A Historical Overview

At its core, a citizen is often understood as a member of a State, bound by its laws and entitled to its protections. However, this simple definition belies a profound complexity. Historically, citizenship has been a privilege, a duty, a birthright, a legal status, and a moral ideal. It has dictated who holds power, who is protected, and who is marginalized. To truly grasp the definition of a citizen, we must embark on a journey through time, examining how philosophers have grappled with this multifaceted identity.

I. Ancient Foundations: The Polis and the Citizen

Our philosophical inquiry into citizenship often begins in ancient Greece, where the polis (city-state) served as the crucible for political thought. Here, the definition of a citizen was inextricably linked to active participation in the State.

Aristotle's Polis: Where Citizenship was a Craft

For Aristotle, as articulated in his Politics (a cornerstone of the Great Books of the Western World), a citizen was not merely someone who resided in a State or participated in its economic life. Instead, he proposed a far more demanding definition:

"A citizen is one who shares in the administration of justice and in the holding of office."

This active engagement in the political and judicial life of the polis was central. It meant:

  • Participation in Assembly: Debating and voting on laws and policies.
  • Service on Juries: Dispensing justice.
  • Holding Office: Taking on administrative roles within the State.

Who was not a citizen in ancient Greece, according to this strict definition?

  • Women: Excluded from public life.
  • Slaves: Considered property, not persons with rights.
  • Foreigners/Metics: Residents who contributed to the economy but lacked political rights.
  • Children: Not yet mature enough for civic duties.
  • Manual Laborers: Often seen as lacking the leisure necessary for political deliberation.

For Aristotle, the State (polis) existed for the sake of the good life, and citizenship was the means by which individuals achieved their highest potential through political virtue and adherence to the law. This definition emphasized duties and active contribution over mere rights.

Generated Image

II. The Social Contract and the Birth of Modern Citizenship

The Enlightenment brought a radical shift in the definition of a citizen, moving away from the communal ideal of the polis towards the individual and their relationship with a sovereign State. The concept of the social contract became paramount, reshaping our understanding of law, rights, and the basis of political authority.

From Subjects to Rights-Bearers: The Enlightenment's Reimagining of the State and Law

Philosophers like Thomas Hobbes, John Locke, and Jean-Jacques Rousseau, whose works are foundational to the Great Books, each offered distinct perspectives on how individuals transition from a "state of nature" into a civil society, thereby defining the nature of the citizen.

| Philosopher | Key Work (Great Books) | View on the Citizen an excellent choice for philosophical exploration. Let's delve into its meaning.

What is a Citizen?

A citizen is a legal member of a State, entitled to rights and owing duties to that State, as defined by its laws. This seemingly straightforward definition becomes incredibly complex when examined through philosophical, historical, and contemporary lenses.

The Philosophical Journey: Defining the Citizen

The definition of a citizen isn't static; it's a dynamic concept shaped by political philosophy, societal needs, and the evolving understanding of human rights.

I. Ancient Foundations: The Polis and the Participatory Citizen

In the classical world, particularly in ancient Greece, the definition of a citizen was intricately tied to the concept of the polis (city-state). Citizenship was not merely a legal status but a demanding role.

Aristotle's Politics: The Active Participant

For Aristotle, whose Politics remains a foundational text in the Great Books of the Western World, a true citizen was one who actively participated in the governance and judicial functions of the State. He famously stated:

"A citizen is one who shares in the administration of justice and in the holding of office."

This excluded vast swathes of the population – women, slaves, foreigners, and those engaged in manual labor – because their lives or status prevented them from dedicating themselves to the public good. The law of the polis defined the citizen by their capacity for virtue and their direct contribution to the State's flourishing.

Key Characteristics of Ancient Citizenship:

  • Active Political Engagement: Voting, holding office, serving on juries.
  • Exclusive Privilege: Limited to a select few.
  • Duty-Oriented: Emphasis on civic responsibilities to the State.
  • Local Identity: Primarily tied to the specific polis.

II. The Social Contract and the Birth of Modern Citizenship

The Enlightenment era introduced revolutionary ideas about individual rights, the nature of government, and the relationship between the individual and the State. The concept of the social contract profoundly reshaped the definition of a citizen.

From Subjects to Rights-Bearers: The Enlightenment's Reimagining of the State and Law

Philosophers like Thomas Hobbes, John Locke, and Jean-Jacques Rousseau, all central figures in the Great Books, explored how individuals consent to form a society and establish a State, thereby transforming themselves from denizens of a "state of nature" into citizens under a common law.

| Philosopher | Key Contribution to Citizenship (Great Books Reference)

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "The Definition of a Citizen philosophy"

Share this post