The Enduring Fabric of Human Society: Marriage as Custom and Convention

Marriage, a cornerstone of human civilization, is far more than a simple union of individuals; it is a profoundly intricate institution, woven from the threads of custom and convention, codified by law, and upheld by a complex web of duty. This article delves into the philosophical underpinnings of marriage and the family unit, drawing insights from the "Great Books of the Western World" to explore how these societal constructs have been understood, challenged, and justified across millennia. From ancient Greek city-states to the Enlightenment, thinkers have grappled with the nature of marriage, its purpose, and its essential role in shaping both individual lives and the broader body politic.

The Enduring Fabric of Human Society: Marriage as Custom and Convention

At its heart, marriage is a social construct, an agreement or understanding that transcends mere biological imperative. While the impulse to procreate and form lasting bonds might be natural, the specific forms and rituals surrounding marriage are undeniably products of custom and convention. These unwritten rules and shared practices dictate everything from who can marry whom, to the ceremonies involved, to the societal expectations placed upon the married couple. They reflect the values, economic structures, and moral compass of a given society, evolving slowly over time but retaining a powerful hold on human behavior.

Philosophical Foundations of Family and Commonwealth

The "Great Books" offer a rich tapestry of perspectives on the family and its relationship to the state:

  • Aristotle's Oikos: For Aristotle, the household (oikos) is the primary and most natural association, preceding the village and the state. Marriage within the oikos is essential for procreation, the daily provision of needs, and the perpetuation of the species, aligning with his teleological view of nature. It's a union "for the sake of life," evolving into a union "for the sake of the good life." The husband and wife, master and slave, parent and child, form a composite economic and social unit from which the political community ultimately springs.
  • Plato's Ideal State: In The Republic, Plato famously challenges conventional family structures, particularly for the guardian class. He proposes a communal upbringing of children, where no child knows its parents, and no parent knows its child, aiming to eliminate private affections that might conflict with absolute loyalty to the state. This radical proposal underscores the philosophical recognition that custom and convention surrounding family are not immutable, but subject to critique and redesign for perceived societal good.
  • The Christian Perspective: Augustine and Aquinas, representing the Christian tradition, viewed marriage through a theological lens. Augustine, in Confessions and City of God, emphasizes the goods of marriage: procreation, fidelity, and the sacramental bond as a remedy for concupiscence. Aquinas, in Summa Theologica, elaborates on marriage as a natural institution, ordered by God for the procreation and education of children, and also as a sacrament, reflecting the union of Christ and the Church. Here, duty is not only social but divinely ordained.

Law, Duty, and the Social Contract of Matrimony

The transition from mere custom and convention to codified law is a crucial step in understanding marriage. Laws concerning marriage establish rights, impose obligations, and provide a framework for resolving disputes, thus formalizing and enforcing societal expectations.

  • From Custom to Law: What begins as a shared understanding (e.g., fidelity, mutual support) eventually finds its way into legal statutes, transforming moral or social expectations into enforceable duties. This codification reflects a society's attempt to stabilize and regulate its most fundamental unit.
  • Locke and the Conjugal Society: John Locke, in Two Treatises of Government, frames the "conjugal society" as a voluntary compact between a man and a woman, primarily for procreation and mutual support, lasting as long as necessary for the rearing of children. He distinguishes it from political society, but also acknowledges the parents' duty to preserve and educate their offspring, and the reciprocal duty of children to honor their parents. This view emphasizes consent and the contractual nature of the union.
  • Rousseau's Natural vs. Civil State: While Rousseau, in works like Emile and The Social Contract, often contrasted the natural state with the corrupting influence of civil society, he still recognized the importance of family within the social order. He saw the family as the "most ancient of all societies, and the only natural one," though even it is maintained by convention. For Rousseau, the duty of parents to children is paramount, and it is the foundation upon which civil society can be built, albeit one that requires careful moral cultivation.
  • Kant's Ethical Framework: Immanuel Kant, in The Metaphysics of Morals, approaches marriage as a legal and ethical institution. He defines it as "the Union of two persons of different sexes for life-long reciprocal possession of their sexual faculties." While this sounds stark, Kant emphasizes the ethical imperative that this union be a "perpetual contract," involving the mutual surrender of one's person, thereby elevating it from mere sexual gratification to a moral relationship that respects the humanity of both parties. The duty here is one of mutual respect and commitment.

The Weight of Duty: Obligations Within the Family Unit

The concept of duty is inextricably linked to marriage and family. These duties are not arbitrary; they are the practical expressions of the customs and conventions that sustain the institution and ensure its societal benefits.

Here are some key duties often emphasized:

  • Spousal Duties:
    • Fidelity: A cornerstone in most cultures, ensuring trust and the legitimacy of offspring.
    • Mutual Support: Providing emotional, financial, and practical aid to one another.
    • Shared Responsibility: Collaborating in household management and child-rearing.
  • Parental Duties:
    • Nurturing and Protection: Ensuring the physical and emotional well-being of children.
    • Education: Imparting knowledge, skills, and moral values necessary for societal integration.
    • Provision: Meeting the material needs of their offspring until maturity.
  • Filial Duties (Children's Duties):
    • Respect and Obedience: Honoring parents, especially in youth.
    • Care: Providing support for aging or infirm parents.

These duties, whether prescribed by law or enforced by social convention, serve to maintain stability within the family and, by extension, within the larger community. They represent the sacrifices and commitments individuals make for the collective good and the perpetuation of society.

(Image: A detailed classical painting depicting a family scene from ancient Greece or Rome, perhaps with a philosopher like Aristotle observing or participating. The figures are dressed in period attire, engaged in domestic tasks or education, highlighting the roles and relationships within the oikos. The scene conveys a sense of order, tradition, and the foundational importance of the family unit to the broader society.)

Conclusion

Marriage, as a construct deeply rooted in custom and convention, has been a constant subject of philosophical inquiry. From the foundational oikos of Aristotle to the contractual theories of Locke and Kant, the "Great Books of the Western World" reveal a continuous effort to understand, define, and justify this complex institution. It is a testament to humanity's enduring need for order, belonging, and the perpetuation of its kind, bound together by the intricate interplay of social norms, legal frameworks, and the profound sense of duty that individuals owe to one another and to the family unit. While its forms may evolve, the philosophical questions surrounding marriage and family remain as pertinent today as they were in the ancient world.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Aristotle Politics Family Oikos Summary""

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""John Locke Conjugal Society Philosophy""

Share this post