At the heart of much philosophical and theological inquiry lies a profound connection between our deepest desires and the concept of sin. This article explores how our inclinations, when misdirected or unchecked, can lead us astray, examining the pivotal role of the will in navigating this complex terrain. From ancient Greek wisdom to medieval Christian thought, the interplay between what we want and what we do has been a persistent and often perplexing subject, suggesting that understanding sin requires a thorough introspection into the very nature of human desire.

Understanding the Nature of Desire

Before we can grasp the connection to sin, we must first confront the multifaceted nature of desire itself. In its most fundamental sense, desire is a longing, an inclination towards something perceived as good or beneficial. Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, speaks of orexis – appetite, spirit, and wish – as fundamental drives towards an end. Plato, similarly, delineates different parts of the soul, each with its own desires: the appetitive for bodily pleasures, the spirited for honor, and the rational for truth.

Desire, in essence, is not inherently negative. It fuels our ambitions, drives our creativity, and forms the basis of love and aspiration. It is the engine of human endeavor, pushing us to seek knowledge, create beauty, and strive for flourishing.

  • Appetitive Desire: Basic biological needs and pleasures (food, drink, comfort).
  • Spirited Desire: Longing for recognition, honor, courage, and self-assertion.
  • Rational Desire: Aspiration for truth, understanding, wisdom, and the good.

However, the problem arises when these desires become disordered, when they seek their objects disproportionately or in ways that contradict a higher good.

The Problem of Disordered Desire and the Genesis of Sin

The connection between desire and sin becomes clear when desire loses its proper orientation. Many traditions, particularly within the Abrahamic faiths, define sin not merely as an action, but as a condition of the heart, a turning away from the divine or the good. This turning away often originates in a desire for something lesser, pursued as if it were the ultimate good.

Saint Augustine, a towering figure in the Great Books of the Western World, eloquently articulates this in his Confessions. He grapples with the concept of concupiscence – a disordered desire for temporal goods – as a root of sin. For Augustine, sin is often a consequence of love misplaced, an attachment to created things over the Creator, or an elevation of self-will above divine will. When the lower desires usurp the place of the higher, when the pursuit of pleasure or power overshadows the pursuit of wisdom or virtue, that is when desire becomes problematic, leading directly to sin.

(Image: A classical painting depicting Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden, with Eve reaching for the forbidden fruit, symbolizing the genesis of sin through a desire for knowledge or pleasure that defies divine command.)

The Crucial Role of the Will

Central to understanding this dynamic is the concept of the will. The will is our faculty of choice, the capacity to assent to or resist our desires, to direct our actions. It is the bridge between our inner inclinations and our outward deeds. The connection between desire and sin is mediated by the will.

Philosophers like Thomas Aquinas, building on Aristotle, posited that the will is naturally inclined towards the good, but it can be misled by a faulty apprehension of what is truly good. We might desire something intensely, but it is our will that makes the final decision to pursue it, often after deliberation by reason. When the will chooses a perceived good that is actually detrimental, or when it succumbs to an intense desire despite rational judgment, that is where sin manifests.

The Will's Dilemma:

  • Freedom of Choice: The capacity to choose between competing desires or between desire and duty.
  • Rational Guidance: The ideal state where reason informs the will, directing desires towards genuine good.
  • Weakness of Will (Akrasia): Knowing what is good but choosing otherwise due to overwhelming desire.
  • Misdirected Will: Actively choosing a lesser good, or even an evil, perceiving it as a greater good.

The struggle with sin is often a struggle of the will against disordered desires. It is the internal battle to align our actions with our highest values, rather than merely succumbing to our immediate appetites.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Augustine's Confessions explained"

Philosophical Perspectives on Desire, Will, and Sin

The connection between desire, will, and sin has been a recurring theme across the philosophical spectrum:

  • Platonism: Views sin as a disharmony within the soul, where the appetitive or spirited parts dominate the rational part, leading to actions that deviate from the good.
  • Aristotelianism: While not using the term "sin" in a theological sense, Aristotle's ethics emphasize virtue as the proper ordering of desires through habit and reason, suggesting that vice arises from an uncontrolled or misdirected desire.
  • Stoicism: Advocates for overcoming passions (excessive desires) through reason and virtue, seeing them as disturbances that prevent a tranquil and rational life.
  • Kantian Ethics: Distinguishes between acting from desire (inclination) and acting from duty (the moral law). For Kant, true moral action transcends mere desire, driven by a rational will.
  • Spinoza: Argues that desire is the very essence of man. While he doesn't use "sin," he suggests that human suffering arises from inadequate ideas and passions, and true freedom comes from understanding and acting according to reason, aligning one's will with the order of nature.

These diverse perspectives, all stemming from the Great Books of the Western World, underscore the enduring philosophical preoccupation with how our inner longings shape our moral landscape.

Conclusion: The Enduring Connection

The connection between sin and desire is not merely a theological construct but a profound philosophical insight into the human condition. Our desires are powerful forces, capable of driving us towards great achievements or profound failings. It is through the faculty of the will that we attempt to navigate these currents, to order our affections, and to choose paths aligned with reason, virtue, or divine command.

Understanding this dynamic requires constant self-reflection and a persistent effort to discern the true nature of our longings. Is our will truly free, or is it perpetually swayed by the strongest desire? This question remains a cornerstone of ethical and metaphysical inquiry, reminding us that the journey towards a virtuous life is, in large part, a journey of mastering the heart's deepest inclinations.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Free Will vs Determinism philosophy"

Share this post