The notion that beauty is merely in the eye of the beholder often overshadows a profound, persistent philosophical inquiry: the undeniable connection between form and beauty. From ancient Greece to the medieval scholastics, thinkers have grappled with the idea that certain inherent structures, proportions, and arrangements – the very form of a thing – are intrinsically linked to its aesthetic appeal. This article explores how the philosophical tradition, particularly through the lens of the Great Books of the Western World, reveals that beauty is not solely subjective but often emerges from objective qualities of form, providing a foundational understanding for our appreciation of art and the natural world.

Ancient Echoes: Plato's Forms and Ideal Beauty

For Plato, the connection between form and beauty was not merely aesthetic but metaphysical. In his philosophy, as elucidated in dialogues like Phaedrus and Symposium, earthly beauties are but imperfect reflections or participations in a transcendent, perfect Form of Beauty existing in the realm of Ideas.

  • The World of Forms: Plato posited an eternal, unchanging realm of perfect Forms, which are the archetypes of everything we perceive. The Form of Beauty itself is the ultimate source of all beautiful things.
  • Participation: A beautiful sculpture, a harmonious piece of music, or a striking natural landscape is beautiful because it partakes, however imperfectly, in this ideal Form. Its specific arrangement, its contours, its symmetry – its very form – allows it to mirror the ideal.
  • Recollection: When we encounter beauty, Plato suggested, we are not just experiencing a sensory pleasure but are, in a sense, recollecting the perfect Form of Beauty that our souls knew before birth. This implies an objective standard for beauty, rooted in the ideal form.

The pursuit of beauty, then, becomes a journey towards understanding these perfect Forms, a journey from the particular to the universal, from the sensory to the intellectual.

Aristotle's Order: Proportion, Symmetry, and Wholeness

While Plato looked to transcendent Forms, Aristotle, his student, grounded the connection between form and beauty more firmly in the empirical world. For Aristotle, beauty was not an ethereal concept but a quality inherent in well-made objects and phenomena, discernible through rational analysis of their form.

In works like the Poetics and Metaphysics, Aristotle emphasized specific formal characteristics that contribute to beauty:

  • Order (Taxis): A beautiful object must have its parts arranged in a coherent and logical sequence. Chaos, by definition, is not beautiful.
  • Proportion (Symmetria): The parts must be appropriately sized relative to each other and to the whole. There must be a harmonious balance, avoiding extremes of too large or too small.
  • Definiteness (Peras): The object must have clear boundaries and a recognizable structure. It must be finite and comprehensible, possessing a distinct beginning, middle, and end.
  • Wholeness (Holon): The object must be a complete entity, where all its parts contribute to the overall unity and purpose, and no part is superfluous or missing.

These formal qualities are not arbitrary; they are what allow an object or a work of art to achieve its telos or purpose effectively, thereby making it beautiful. The form of a well-designed ship, for instance, is beautiful because it perfectly serves its function of sailing.

Medieval Musings: Aquinas and the Attributes of Beauty

Centuries later, Thomas Aquinas, synthesizing Aristotelian thought with Christian theology, further articulated the philosophical connection between form and beauty. For Aquinas, beauty was an attribute of God and, by extension, present in creation, identifiable through specific formal qualities.

Aquinas identified three conditions for beauty:

  1. Integritas sive perfectio (Integrity or Perfection): A thing is beautiful if it is complete and whole, lacking nothing essential to its form. A mutilated object, no matter how potentially grand, loses its beauty.
  2. Consonantia sive debita proportio (Consonance or Due Proportion): The parts of a beautiful thing must be in proper relation to one another and to the whole. This echoes Aristotle's emphasis on symmetry and proportion in form.
  3. Claritas sive perspicuitas (Clarity or Radiance): A beautiful thing must possess a certain luminosity or brilliance of form that makes it readily intelligible and striking to the mind. This clarity allows the inherent form to shine through.

For Aquinas, beauty was not just about pleasing the senses but about the intellect grasping the inherent order and perfection of a thing's form.

The Artist's Pursuit: Crafting Beauty through Form

The enduring philosophical insights into the connection between form and beauty have profoundly influenced the creation of art. Artists, whether consciously or instinctively, manipulate formal elements to evoke aesthetic pleasure and meaning. From the balanced composition of a Renaissance painting to the rhythmic structure of a classical symphony, the mastery lies in the manipulation of form.

(Image: A detailed photograph of the Discobolus (Discus Thrower) by Myron, showcasing its classical Greek proportions, dynamic yet balanced posture, and the elegant curve of the body in motion. The marble surface is smooth, highlighting the anatomical precision and the idealized human form. The figure is captured from a slightly low angle, emphasizing its heroic stature and athletic grace, demonstrating a perfect blend of symmetry, tension, and fluid form.)

The sculptor meticulously carves stone to achieve ideal proportions; the architect designs spaces with harmonious ratios; the composer arranges notes and silences into intricate patterns. In each case, the artist's skill is in imbuing material with a form that resonates with our innate appreciation for order, balance, and clarity, thereby creating beauty. The art object becomes a tangible manifestation of these philosophical principles.

Conclusion: The Indelible Connection

The philosophical journey through the Great Books of the Western World consistently reveals that the connection between form and beauty is far from superficial. From Plato's transcendent ideals to Aristotle's empirical observations and Aquinas's theological synthesis, the consensus points to beauty being inextricably linked to objective qualities of structure, order, proportion, and integrity. While individual taste certainly plays a role, the fundamental capacity to perceive and appreciate beauty seems rooted in our ability to recognize and respond to well-ordered forms—a testament to the profound and enduring relationship between how things are made and how they move us.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Plato's Theory of Forms and Aesthetics Explained""

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Aristotle on Art and Beauty: Poetics Summary""

Share this post