The Enduring Enigma of Angelic Being: A Philosophical Journey

For millennia, humanity has looked beyond the tangible, pondering the existence of beings that transcend our material world. Among these, the concept of the angel stands as one of the most persistent and philosophically rich. This article embarks on a journey through Western thought, particularly as illuminated by the Great Books of the Western World, to unpack the intricate philosophical and theological discussions surrounding the Being of angels. We'll explore how thinkers from antiquity to the high Middle Ages grappled with their nature, their mode of existence, and their relationship to the divine and human realms, often touching upon their very Form as pure intellects. From Plato's world of Forms to Aquinas's meticulous scholasticism, understanding angels offers a profound lens into metaphysics, epistemology, and the very structure of reality itself.

Tracing the Roots: Angels in Early Philosophy and Theology

The idea of non-human, spiritual intelligences predates organized Christian Theology. Ancient philosophies often posited intermediaries between gods and mortals, or rational principles governing the cosmos. While not always explicitly "angels" in the Judeo-Christian sense, these concepts laid foundational groundwork.

  • Platonic Echoes: Plato's realm of pure Forms, existing independently of the physical world, offered a conceptual space for non-material realities. Though Plato himself didn't discuss angels, his ideas about perfect, immutable essences influenced later thinkers who sought to define spiritual Being. The very notion that something could exist perfectly and immaterially, as a pure Form, set the stage for understanding angelic nature.
  • Aristotelian Movers: Aristotle's concept of "unmoved movers" – pure intelligences that cause the motion of the celestial spheres through their sheer desirability – provided another philosophical precursor. These movers are immaterial and eternal, existing as pure actuality, resonating with later descriptions of angels as pure intellects.
  • Early Christian Synthesis: As Christianity emerged, it integrated existing philosophical concepts with its scriptural understanding of angels. Early Church Fathers, like Augustine of Hippo, began to synthesize these ideas, pondering the creation, nature, and purpose of these spiritual entities. Augustine, in City of God, discusses angels within the divine order, emphasizing their role as God's messengers and servants, creatures of intellect and will, distinct from both God and humanity.

Scholastic Metaphysics: Angels as Pure Forms and Intelligences

The high Middle Ages witnessed the most rigorous philosophical examination of angels, primarily through the work of Saint Thomas Aquinas. His magnum opus, Summa Theologica, dedicates extensive sections to the nature of angels, pushing the boundaries of what it means for something to possess Being without matter.

The Essence of Angelic Being: Pure Form

For Aquinas, angels are fundamentally different from humans. While humans are a composite of matter and Form (body and soul), angels are subsistent Forms. This means their essence is their existence; they are pure intellects, entirely devoid of matter.

Key Characteristics of Angelic Being (Aquinas):

Characteristic Description Philosophical Implication
Pure Form/Intellect Angels have no body; their Form is their entire Being. They are pure spirit. Challenges our human-centric understanding of existence; implies a higher mode of Being.
Immateriality They are not composed of matter; thus, they are not subject to corruption, decay, or spatial limitations in the same way as physical entities. Explores the concept of non-physical existence and its implications for power and knowledge.
Immortality As pure Forms without matter, they are inherently immortal. Raises questions about divine creation and the nature of eternal existence.
Individual Species Each angel is a species unto itself. Unlike humans, where many individuals share the same human Form, each angel's Form is unique and exhaustive of its species. Highlights their perfection and distinctness, emphasizing their non-material mode of differentiation.
Direct Knowledge Angels acquire knowledge not through senses or abstraction (like humans), but directly through infused ideas from God. Probes different modes of cognition and the hierarchy of knowing.
Free Will Despite their perfect intellect, angels possess free will, capable of choosing good or evil (e.g., the fall of Lucifer). Addresses the problem of evil and the nature of moral agency in perfect Beings.

(Image: A detailed medieval manuscript illustration depicting a choir of angels, some with multiple wings and varying numbers of eyes, surrounding a central divine light. Their forms are ethereal and luminous, suggesting immateriality, while their expressions convey deep contemplation and devotion, emphasizing their intellectual and spiritual nature.)

The Act of Knowing and Willing

Because angels are pure intellects, their mode of knowing is instantaneous and comprehensive. They grasp truths directly, without discursive reasoning. Their will is equally perfect, always choosing what their intellect perceives as good, unless corrupted by pride (as in the case of fallen angels). This perfect intellect and will are central to their Being and their function within the divine order.

Angelic Hierarchies and Purpose in Theology

Beyond their metaphysical Being, Theology also delves into the purpose and structure of angels. Dionysius the Areopagite, whose work influenced Aquinas, developed an elaborate system of nine choirs of angels, arranged in three hierarchies:

  1. First Hierarchy: Seraphim, Cherubim, Thrones (closest to God, focused on contemplation and divine love)
  2. Second Hierarchy: Dominions, Virtues, Powers (govern the cosmos and mediate divine power)
  3. Third Hierarchy: Principalities, Archangels, Angels (closest to humanity, involved in human affairs and messages)

This complex hierarchy reflects a universe ordered by divine wisdom, with angels playing crucial roles as messengers, guardians, and instruments of God's providence. Their very existence reinforces the idea of a structured cosmos, where different modes of Being fulfill specific functions.

The Enduring Concept: Angels Beyond the Medieval

While the detailed scholastic discussions might seem distant to modern thought, the concept of angelic Being continues to resonate.

  • Metaphorical Angels: In secular contexts, "angel" often becomes a metaphor for goodness, purity, or a guiding presence. This reflects the enduring human yearning for transcendence and benevolent forces.
  • The Philosophical Challenge: Even if one doesn't believe in literal angels, the philosophical questions they raise remain pertinent: What constitutes non-material Being? Can pure intellect exist? How do we understand different Forms of existence? These questions push us to examine our own assumptions about reality.
  • Spiritual Exploration: For many, angels remain vital figures in spiritual and religious life, embodying divine connection and protection.

The journey through the concept of angelic Being is not merely an exercise in historical Theology; it's an exploration of the very boundaries of philosophical inquiry, challenging us to consider realities beyond our immediate grasp and to ponder the myriad Forms existence might take.

YouTube Suggestions:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Thomas Aquinas on Angels Philosophy"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Metaphysics of Pure Form Angelic Beings"

Share this post