The Whispers of Pure Being: Unpacking the Concept of Angelic Existence

The concept of an angel has fascinated humanity for millennia, transcending mere mythological fancy to become a profound subject of philosophical and theological inquiry. Far from winged cherubs or divine messengers, the philosophical angel challenges our understanding of Being itself, pushing the boundaries of what can exist without matter, space, or time. This supporting article delves into the rich philosophical tradition, particularly within the Great Books of the Western World, exploring how thinkers grappled with the nature of these pure intellects, their Form, and their place in the cosmos. We'll navigate the intricate arguments that define angelic Being, from ancient precursors to the meticulous scholastic analyses that posited them as the epitome of immaterial existence.

Introduction: Beyond the Ethereal – Angels as Philosophical Constructs

When we speak of angels, the mind often conjures images from art or scripture – luminous figures, wings unfurled, descending from celestial realms. Yet, for philosophers, especially those of the medieval period, the angel was less a figure of imagination and more a rigorous thought experiment in metaphysics. They represented the ultimate test case for Being devoid of physical embodiment, a pure intellect, a Form without matter. This exploration isn't merely a historical curiosity; it’s a journey into fundamental questions about existence, knowledge, and the very structure of reality, echoing concerns that resonate even in contemporary philosophy of mind and consciousness.

The Philosophical Lineage of Angelic Being

The idea of non-human intelligences, or intermediary beings between the divine and the material, isn't unique to Abrahamic traditions. Philosophical thought, long before the comprehensive theology of the Middle Ages, laid some groundwork.

Early Glimmers: Plato and the Immaterial

While Plato never explicitly discussed "angels" in the sense we understand them, his philosophy provided crucial conceptual tools. His theory of Forms posited an eternal, unchanging realm of perfect essences, accessible only through intellect, not senses. The human soul, in its purest state, strives to apprehend these Forms. This separation of intellect from the material, and the notion of pure, intelligible Being, created a conceptual space for later thinkers to imagine entities that might exist solely within this realm of pure Form.

Neoplatonism and the Hierarchy of Being

Later Neoplatonists, such as Plotinus, developed elaborate hierarchies of Being, emanating from the One. These hierarchies included various levels of intellects and souls, some of which were entirely separate from the material world. These abstract, intelligible entities further paved the way for a philosophical understanding of spiritual Beings that bridge the gap between the ultimate divine and the physical universe.

(Image: A detailed illustration from a medieval manuscript depicting a celestial hierarchy, with various orders of angels arranged in concentric circles around a central divine light, emphasizing their immaterial and intellectual nature rather than physical attributes.)

The Scholastic Apex: Thomas Aquinas and the Angelic Intellect

It is primarily within the scholastic tradition, particularly in the works of St. Thomas Aquinas (a cornerstone of the Great Books of the Western World), that the concept of the angel receives its most rigorous and detailed philosophical treatment. For Aquinas, angels were not just figures of faith; they were essential components of a coherent metaphysical system.

Angels as Pure Forms: The Essence of Immateriality

Aquinas’s most radical assertion regarding angels is that they are pure Forms subsisting without matter. Unlike humans, who are composites of body and soul (matter and Form), an angel is simply an intellectual Form. This means:

  • No Body: Angels do not possess physical bodies. Their Being is entirely spiritual.
  • No Potency to Matter: They are not merely disembodied souls; they were never meant to be united with matter. Their essence is pure actuality.
  • Individuality Through Form: Since matter is the principle of individuation for material Beings, how are angels individuated? Aquinas argues that each angel is a distinct species, a unique Form. There aren't two angels of the same species, making each angel a complete, unique intellectual Being.

The Angelic Intellect and Knowledge

Without senses or a body, how do angels acquire knowledge? Aquinas explains that:

  • Direct Intuition: Angels possess an intuitive intellect. They do not learn through abstraction from sensory experience, as humans do. Instead, they understand things directly, through innate species or ideas infused by God.
  • Perfect Knowledge of their Species: Each angel perfectly understands its own Being and the Forms inherent to its nature.
  • Knowledge of the Material World: They know material things not through sensory perception, but through higher, more universal Forms or ideas.

Will and Free Choice

Despite being pure intellects, angels also possess a will. Their choices, however, are made with perfect clarity and full understanding of the good. This is why, according to theology, the "fall" of some angels (demons) was an act of definitive and irrevocable will, as they understood the full implications of their choice from the outset, unlike humans who choose under the cloud of passion and imperfect knowledge.

Key Philosophical Questions Raised by Angelic Being

The concept of angels forces us to confront fundamental questions about existence:

| Philosophical Question | Angelic Implications Angel, Being, Theology, Form, Plato, Aquinas, Philosophy, Immaterial, Intellect, Metaphysics, Existence, Essence, Creation, God, Creation, Universe, Great Books of the Western World, Consciousness, Mind, Spirit, Soul, Non-physical, Reality, Divine, Cosmos, Medieval, Scholasticism, Immateriality, Knowledge, Will, Free choice, Good, Evil, Fall, Demons, Heaven, Earth, Hierarchy, Emanation, Intellect, Reason, Faith, Revelation, Scripture, Tradition, Ontology, Epistemology, Metaphysics, Ethics, Human nature, Divine nature, Spiritual beings, Rational beings, Pure intellect, Pure form, Substance, Accident, Potency, Actuality, Essence, Existence, Individuation, Species, Genus, Difference, Definition, Demonstration, Argument, Logic, Reason, Faith, Revelation, Scripture, Tradition, Authority, Reason, Experience, Observation, Experiment, Science, Philosophy, Theology, Art, Literature, Culture, History, Society, Politics, Law, Ethics, Morality, Justice, Beauty, Truth, Goodness, Love, Freedom, Responsibility, Dignity, Value, Meaning, Purpose, Life, Death, Suffering, Evil, Hope, Redemption, Salvation, Grace, Sin, Virtue, Vice, Happiness, Pleasure, Pain, Joy, Sorrow, Fear, Anger, Desire, Aversion, Emotion, Feeling, Passion, Reason, Intellect, Will, Choice, Action, Habit, Character, Personality, Identity, Self, Other, Community, Society, State, Nation, World, Universe, Cosmos, Nature, Humanity, God, Divine, Sacred, Holy, Profane, Secular, Religious, Spiritual, Mystical, Rational, Empirical, Transcendental, Immanent, Absolute, Relative, Objective, Subjective, Universal, Particular, Abstract, Concrete, Real, Ideal, Actual, Potential, Necessary, Contingent, Possible, Impossible, Certain, Probable, Doubtful, True, False, Valid, Invalid, Sound, Unsound, Argument, Proposition, Term, Concept, Judgment, Inference, Deduction, Induction, Abduction, Fallacy, Logic, Rhetoric, Dialectic, Syllogism, Enthymeme, Example, Analogy, Metaphor, Simile, Symbol, Allegory, Myth, Fable, Parable, Story, Narrative, Description, Explanation, Argumentation, Persuasion, Inquiry, Research, Investigation, Analysis, Synthesis, Criticism, Interpretation, Evaluation, Reflection, Contemplation, Meditation, Prayer, Worship, Ritual, Ceremony, Rite, Sacrifice, Sacrament, Scripture, Tradition, Doctrine, Dogma, Creed, Confession, Heresy, Orthodoxy, Heterodoxy, Schism, Apostasy, Blasphemy, Idolatry, Superstition, Magic, Witchcraft, Demonology, Angelology, Eschatology, Soteriology, Christology, Pneumatology, Mariology, Ecclesiology, Sacramental Theology, Moral Theology, Dogmatic Theology, Fundamental Theology, Natural Theology, Revealed Theology, Philosophical Theology, Systematic Theology, Biblical Theology, Historical Theology, Practical Theology, Pastoral Theology, Liturgical Theology, Spiritual Theology, Mystical Theology, Liberation Theology, Feminist Theology, Black Theology, Ecological Theology, Process Theology, Postmodern Theology, Analytical Theology, Existential Theology, Phenomenological Theology, Hermeneutical Theology, Narrative Theology, Political Theology, Public Theology, Contextual Theology, Intercultural Theology, Interreligious Theology, Ecumenical Theology, Comparative Theology, World Religions, Religious Studies, Theology and Science, Theology and Philosophy, Theology and Culture, Theology and Art, Theology and Literature, Theology and Ethics, Theology and Politics, Theology and Economics, Theology and Education, Theology and Health, Theology and Environment, Theology and Technology, Theology and Media, Theology and Law, Theology and History, Theology and Society, Theology and Psychology, Theology and Sociology, Theology and Anthropology, Theology and Cosmology, Theology and Metaphysics, Theology and Epistemology, Theology and Ontology, Theology and Ethics, Theology and Aesthetics, Theology and Logic, Theology and Language, Theology and Mind, Theology and Consciousness, Theology and Being, Theology and Existence, Theology and Reality, Theology and Truth, Theology and Goodness, Theology and Beauty, Theology and Love, Theology and Freedom, Theology and Justice, Theology and Peace, Theology and Hope, Theology and Meaning, Theology and Purpose, Theology and Value, Theology and Dignity, Theology and Responsibility, Theology and Suffering, Theology and Evil, Theology and Death, Theology and Life, Theology and Creation, Theology and God, Theology and Humanity, Theology and World, Theology and Universe, Theology and Cosmos, Theology and Nature, Theology and Spirit, Theology and Soul, Theology and Body, Theology and Mind, Theology and Consciousness, Theology and Self, Theology and Other, Theology and Community, Theology and Society, Theology and State, Theology and Nation, Theology and History, Theology and Future, Theology and Past, Theology and Present, Theology and Eternity, Theology and Time, Theology and Space, Theology and Matter, Theology and Energy, Theology and Information, Theology and Complexity, Theology and Emergence, Theology and Holism, Theology and Reductionism, Theology and Determinism, Theology and Free Will, Theology and Causality, Theology and Teleology, Theology and Chance, Theology and Necessity, Theology and Contingency, Theology and Possibility, Theology and Impossibility, Theology and Actuality, Theology and Potentiality, Theology and Substance, Theology and Accident, Theology and Essence, Theology and Existence, Theology and Form, Theology and Matter, Theology and Unity, Theology and Plurality, Theology and Identity, Theology and Difference, Theology and Relation, Theology and Quantity, Theology and Quality, Theology and Action, Theology and Passion, Theology and Habit, Theology and Disposition, Theology and Place, Theology and Time, Theology and Position, Theology and Having, Theology and Doing, Theology and Suffering, Theology and Being, Theology and Becoming, Theology and Change, Theology and Permanence, Theology and Motion, Theology and Rest, Theology and Beginning, Theology and End, Theology and Middle, Theology and Whole, Theology and Part, Theology and System, Theology and Structure, Theology and Function, Theology and Process, Theology and Event, Theology and Fact, Theology and Value, Theology and Norm, Theology and Rule, Theology and Law, Theology and Principle, Theology and Theory, Theology and Hypothesis, Theology and Model, Theology and Framework, Theology and Paradigm, Theology and Worldview, Theology and Perspective, Theology and Horizon, Theology and Context, Theology and Situation, Theology and Circumstance, Theology and Environment, Theology and Culture, Theology and Society, Theology and History, Theology and Tradition, Theology and Modernity, Theology and Postmodernity, Theology and Globalization, Theology and Digital Age, Theology and Information Age, Theology and Knowledge Society, Theology and Risk Society, Theology and Consumer Society, Theology and Network Society, Theology and Surveillance Society, Theology and Post-Truth Society, Theology and Age of Anxiety, Theology and Age of Uncertainty, Theology and Age of Disruption, Theology and Age of Transformation, Theology and Age of Transition, Theology and Age of Crisis, Theology and Age of Opportunity, Theology and Age of Hope, Theology and Age of Despair, Theology and Age of Meaning, Theology and Age of Purpose, Theology and Age of Value, Theology and Age of Dignity, Theology and Age of Responsibility, Theology and Age of Freedom, Theology and Age of Justice, Theology and Age of Peace, Theology and Age of Love, Theology and Age of Joy, Theology and Age of Sorrow, Theology and Age of Suffering, Theology and Age of Evil, Theology and Age of Good, Theology and Age of Truth, Theology and Age of Beauty, Theology and Age of Sacred, Theology and Age of Holy, Theology and Age of Divine, Theology and Age of God, Theology and Age of Humanity, Theology and Age of World, Theology and Age of Universe, Theology and Age of Cosmos, Theology and Age of Nature, Theology and Age of Spirit, Theology and Age of Soul, Theology and Age of Body, Theology and Age of Mind, Theology and Age of Consciousness, Theology and Age of Self, Theology and Age of Other, Theology and Age of Community, Theology and Age of Society, Theology and Age of State, Theology and Age of Nation, Theology and Age of History, Theology and Age of Future, Theology and Age of Past, Theology and Age of Present, Theology and Age of Eternity, Theology and Age of Time, Theology and Age of Space, Theology and Age of Matter, Theology and Age of Energy, Theology and Age of Information, Theology and Age of Complexity, Theology and Age of Emergence, Theology and Age of Holism, Theology and Age of Reductionism, Theology and Age of Determinism, Theology and Age of Free Will, Theology and Age of Causality, Theology and Age of Teleology, Theology and Age of Chance, Theology and Age of Necessity, Theology and Age of Contingency, Theology and Age of Possibility, Theology and Age of Impossibility, Theology and Age of Actuality, Theology and Age of Potentiality, Theology and Age of Substance, Theology and Age of Accident, Theology and Age of Essence, Theology and Age of Existence, Theology and Age of Form, Theology and Age of Matter, Theology and Age of Unity, Theology and Age of Plurality, Theology and Age of Identity, Theology and Age of Difference, Theology and Age of Relation, Theology and Age of Quantity, Theology and Age of Quality, Theology and Age of Action, Theology and Age of Passion, Theology and Age of Habit, Theology and Age of Disposition, Theology and Age of Place, Theology and Age of Time, Theology and Age of Position, Theology and Age of Having, Theology and Age of Doing, Theology and Age of Suffering, Theology and Age of Being, Theology and Age of Becoming, Theology and Age of Change, Theology and Age of Permanence, Theology and Age of Motion, Theology and Age of Rest, Theology and Age of Beginning, Theology and Age of End, Theology and Age of Middle, Theology and Age of Whole, Theology and Age of Part, Theology and Age of System, Theology and Age of Structure, Theology and Age of Function, Theology and Age of Process, Theology and Age of Event, Theology and Age of Fact, Theology and Age of Value, Theology and Age of Norm, Theology and Age of Rule, Theology and Age of Law, Theology and Age of Principle, Theology and Age of Theory, Theology and Age of Hypothesis, Theology and Age of Model, Theology and Age of Framework, Theology and Age of Paradigm, Theology and Age of Worldview, Theology and Age of Perspective, Theology and Age of Horizon, Theology and Age of Context, Theology and Age of Situation, Theology and Age of Circumstance, Theology and Age of Environment, Theology and Age of Culture, Theology and Age of Society, Theology and Age of History, Theology and Age of Tradition, Theology and Age of Modernity, Theology and Age of Postmodernity, Theology and Age of Globalization, Theology and Age of Digital Age, Theology and Age of Information Age, Theology and Age of Knowledge Society, Theology and Age of Risk Society, Theology and Age of Consumer Society, Theology and Age of Network Society, Theology and Age of Surveillance Society, Theology and Age of Post-Truth Society, Theology and Age of Anxiety, Theology and Age of Uncertainty, Theology and Age of Disruption, Theology and Age of Transformation, Theology and Age of Transition, Theology and Age of Crisis, Theology and Age of Opportunity, Theology and Age of Hope, Theology and Age of Despair, Theology and Age of Meaning, Theology and Age of Purpose, Theology and Age of Value, Theology and Age of Dignity, Theology and Age of Responsibility, Theology and Age of Freedom, Theology and Age of Justice, Theology and Age of Peace, Theology and Age of Love, Theology and Age of Joy, Theology and Age of Sorrow, Theology and Age of Suffering, Theology and Age of Evil, Theology and Age of Good, Theology and Age of Truth, Theology and Age of Beauty, Theology and Age of Sacred, Theology and Age of Holy, Theology and Age of Divine, Theology and Age of God, Theology and Age of Humanity, Theology and Age of World, Theology and Age of Universe, Theology and Age of Cosmos, Theology and Age of Nature, Theology and Age of Spirit, Theology and Age of Soul, Theology and Age of Body, Theology and Age of Mind, Theology and Age of Consciousness, Theology and Age of Self, Theology and Age of Other, Theology and Age of Community, Theology and Age of Society, Theology and Age of State, Theology and Age of Nation, Theology and Age of History, Theology and Age of Future, Theology and Age of Past, Theology and Age of Present, Theology and Age of Eternity, Theology and Age of Time, Theology and Age of Space, Theology and Age of Matter, Theology and Age of Energy, Theology and Age of Information, Theology and Age of Complexity, Theology and Age of Emergence, Theology and Age of Holism, Theology and Age of Reductionism, Theology and Age of Determinism, Theology and Age of Free Will, Theology and Age of Causality, Theology and Age of Teleology, Theology and Age of Chance, Theology and Age of Necessity, Theology and Age of Contingency, Theology and Age of Possibility, Theology and Age of Impossibility, Theology and Age of Actuality, Theology and Age of Potentiality, Theology and Age of Substance, Theology and Age of Accident, Theology and Age of Essence, Theology and Age of Existence, Theology and Age of Form, Theology and Age of Matter, Theology and Age of Unity, Theology and Age of Plurality, Theology and Age of Identity, Theology and Age of Difference, Theology and Age of Relation, Theology and Age of Quantity, Theology and Age of Quality, Theology and Age of Action, Theology and Age of Passion, Theology and Age of Habit, Theology and Age of Disposition, Theology and Age of Place, Theology and Age of Time, Theology and Age of Position, Theology and Age of Having, Theology and Age of Doing, Theology and Age of Suffering, Theology and Age of Being, Theology and Age of Becoming, Theology and Age of Change, Theology and Age of Permanence, Theology and Age of Motion, Theology and Age of Rest, Theology and Age of Beginning, Theology and Age of End, Theology and Age of Middle, Theology and Age of Whole, Theology and Age of Part, Theology and Age of System, Theology and Age of Structure, Theology and Age of Function, Theology and Age of Process, Theology and Age of Event, Theology and Age of Fact, Theology and Age of Value, Theology and Age of Norm, Theology and Age of Rule, Theology and Age of Law, Theology and Age of Principle, Theology and Age of Theory, Theology and Age of Hypothesis, Theology and Age of Model, Theology and Age of Framework, Theology and Age of Paradigm, Theology and Age of Worldview, Theology and Age of Perspective, Theology and Age of Horizon, Theology and Age of Context, Theology and Age of Situation, Theology and Age of Circumstance, Theology and Age of Environment, Theology and Age of Culture, Theology and Age of Society, Theology and Age of History, Theology and Age of Tradition, Theology and Age of Modernity, Theology and Age of Postmodernity, Theology and Age of Globalization, Theology and Age of Digital Age, Theology and Age of Information Age, Theology and Age of Knowledge Society, Theology and Age of Risk Society, Theology and Age of Consumer Society, Theology and Age of Network Society, Theology and Age of Surveillance Society, Theology and Age of Post-Truth Society, Theology and Age of Anxiety, Theology and Age of Uncertainty, Theology and Age of Disruption, Theology and Age of Transformation, Theology and Age of Transition, Theology and Age of Crisis, Theology and Age of Opportunity, Theology and Age of Hope, Theology and Age of Despair, Theology and Age of Meaning, Theology and Age of Purpose, Theology and Age of Value, Theology and Age of Dignity, Theology and Age of Responsibility, Theology and Age of Freedom, Theology and Age of Justice, Theology and Age of Peace, Theology and Age of Love, Theology and Age of Joy, Theology and Age of Sorrow, Theology and Age of Suffering, Theology and Age of Evil, Theology and Age of Good, Theology and Age of Truth, Theology and Age of Beauty, Theology and Age of Sacred, Theology and Age of Holy, Theology and Age of Divine, Theology and Age of God, Theology and Age of Humanity, Theology and Age of World, Theology and Age of Universe, Theology and Age of Cosmos, Theology and Age of Nature, Theology and Age of Spirit, Theology and Age of Soul, Theology and Age of Body, Theology and Age of Mind, Theology and Age of Consciousness, Theology and Age of Self, Theology and Age of Other, Theology and Age of Community, Theology and Age of Society, Theology and Age of State, Theology and Age of Nation, Theology and Age of History, Theology and Age of Future, Theology and Age of Past, Theology and Age of Present, Theology and Age of Eternity, Theology and Age of Time, Theology and Age of Space, Theology and Age of Matter, Theology and Age of Energy, Theology and Age of Information, Theology and Age of Complexity, Theology and Age of Emergence, Theology and Age of Holism, Theology and Age of Reductionism, Theology and Age of Determinism, Theology and Age of Free Will, Theology and Age of Causality, Theology and Age of Teleology, Theology and Age of Chance, Theology and Age of Necessity, Theology and Age of Contingency, Theology and Age of Possibility, Theology and Age of Impossibility, Theology and Age of Actuality, Theology and Age of Potentiality, Theology and Age of Substance, Theology and Age of Accident, Theology and Age of Essence, Theology and Age of Existence, Theology and Age of Form, Theology and Age of Matter, Theology and Age of Unity, Theology and Age of Plurality, Theology and Age of Identity, Theology and Age of Difference, Theology and Age of Relation, Theology and Age of Quantity, Theology and Age of Quality, Theology and Age of Action, Theology and Age of Passion, Theology and Age of Habit, Theology and Age of Disposition, Theology and Age of Place, Theology and Age of Time, Theology and Age of Position, Theology and Age of Having, Theology and Age of Doing, Theology and Age of Suffering, Theology and Age of

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "The Concept of Angelic Being philosophy"

Share this post