The day after a political landslide is not usually the best time to ask people for nuance.

The winners feel vindicated.
The losers feel threatened.
The pundits rush to explain what “the voters said.”
Each side searches for proof that history has turned in its direction.

And yet it is precisely at such moments—when the political ground shifts visibly beneath our feet—that we most need to think more deeply about what ground actually holds.

When I spoke with Justin Giboney on Created in the Image of God, I kept returning in my own mind to a framework that has become increasingly important to me over the years: the difference between the Curriculum and the Laboratory.

By the Curriculum, I mean God’s revealed Word.
By the Laboratory, I mean God’s creation—human life as it is actually lived, tested, suffered, loved, broken, and rebuilt in the real world.

Not everyone accepts the Curriculum. That is obvious enough. But everyone lives in the Laboratory. Everyone eventually has to deal with reality. Everyone eventually runs experiments in family life, civic life, economics, sexuality, speech, justice, power, community, truth, and tribalism. And over time, the Laboratory reveals what works, what corrodes, what heals, what destroys, what dignifies, and what dehumanizes.

That is why shared ground is still possible, even in a deeply divided society.

Not easy.
Not automatic.
But possible.

And it is also why Christians need to learn how to frame that shared ground better.

Too often, religious people assume that if someone rejects the Curriculum, there is no conversation to be had. Or, on the other side, they surrender their convictions in order to remain audible in public. Both instincts are failures of nerve. The first gives up on persuasion. The second gives up on truth.

Justin is trying to chart a better way.

His central point is simple enough to say and very difficult to practice: compassion and conviction are not opposites.

That should not be a controversial claim for Christians. It ought to be basic discipleship. But our political order is structured to force a false choice. We are told, implicitly and explicitly, that if we care deeply about moral order, we must be indifferent to suffering. Or if we care deeply about suffering, we must loosen our grip on moral truth. One side majors in conviction and often neglects compassion. The other side majors in compassion and often neglects conviction. And then each side flatters itself for possessing the better half of Morality.

Justin’s argument—and I think he is right—is that this is not Christian faithfulness. It is partisan formation.

The Christian calling is not truth or love. It is truth in love.
Not conviction without mercy.
Not mercy without moral clarity.
Not justice severed from righteousness.
Not righteousness severed from neighbor-love.

That sounds obvious until you try to live it in public.

Because politics rewards simplification. It rewards emotional sorting. It rewards team loyalty. It rewards moral asymmetry: indulgence toward your own side, severity toward the other. Which is why Justin’s second major point matters so much:

Christians cannot outsource their public witness.

That sentence alone could save a lot of souls from political captivity.

The temptation, of course, is understandable. Political parties offer ready-made scripts. They hand us narratives, enemies, slogans, emotional cues, hierarchies of concern, and a vocabulary of belonging. They tell us not just what to think, but often how to feel. And if we accept the package, we no longer have to do the harder work of Christian moral reasoning.

But that comes at a cost.

If a believer hands over his public witness to a party, he is no longer thinking as a Christian in public. He is thinking as a partisan with a Christian accent. He will judge his own side by one standard and the other side by another. He will excuse in allies what he condemns in opponents. He will stop asking, “What is the righteous position here?” and begin asking, “What must I say to help my side win?”

That is not discipleship.

Justin made the point well: a Christian may lean toward one party or another. That is not the issue. The issue is what happens on the issues where “your side” is wrong. Do you go silent? Do you rationalize? Do you pretend not to see it? Do you explain it away because the alternative feels worse?

That is where public witness is tested.

And this is where my Curriculum and Laboratory framework becomes especially useful. Believers in the Bible begin with the Curriculum. We are shaped by revelation, by command, by story, by doctrine, by stories with morals we trust, by the law of Moses, by the life and teachings of Christ. But when we bring those convictions into public life, we should not be surprised that the Laboratory keeps confirming what the Curriculum already taught.

For example:

  • If you sow contempt, you reap fragmentation.
  • If you dehumanize opponents, you destabilize public trust.
  • If you sever freedom from truth, both become brittle.
  • If you deny moral limits in the name of liberation, the vulnerable suffer first.
  • If you preach justice while practicing hypocrisy, cynicism grows.
  • If you celebrate tribal victory over human dignity, social peace decays.

These are not merely “religious opinions.” These are observable realities in the Laboratory.

And if Christians learned to speak that way more often—without diluting conviction—they might be better at finding shared civic ground with people who do not yet accept the Curriculum but are living, as we all are, in the same created order.

That brings us to the third major point, and perhaps the hardest one:

The church cannot heal the nation while accepting its own divisions.

This may be the most painful part of Justin’s witness, because he is not merely critiquing “the culture.” He is witnessing to the people of God.

A divided church cannot credibly preach reconciliation.
A racially complacent church cannot credibly preach human dignity.
A politically tribal church cannot credibly preach the Lordship of Christ over all earthly powers.

And yet many Christians seem strangely comfortable with precisely those contradictions.

Justin was careful here, and rightly so. He did not argue that every church must look the same demographically in order to be faithful. He did argue that Christians have become far too comfortable with distance, suspicion, and separation. The issue is not optics. The issue is obedience. The issue is whether the body of Christ really believes it is one body when race, class, party, and culture put pressure on that confession.

If the church mirrors the world’s most hardened fractures, then it has little standing to lecture the nation about unity.

Again, the Laboratory proves the point. A church that cannot fellowship across race and politics will not produce citizens capable of doing so either. A people who cannot practice reconciliation in worship will not suddenly become peacemakers in city hall. A divided discipleship yields a divided public life.

So the article I am writing the day after a political landslide is not one about who won.

It is about whether any of us still know how to stand on ground that is deeper than victory.

Justin Giboney’s work reminds us that such ground still exists:

  • human dignity
  • freedom of conscience
  • truthful speech
  • neighbor-love
  • justice joined to moral order
  • compassion joined to conviction
  • Christian witness that is not for sale to party machinery
  • a church willing to do its own housecleaning before trying to save the republic

That is shared ground.

Not because everyone already agrees on it fully, but because the Laboratory keeps testifying to its necessity.

You do not need to accept every line of the Curriculum to notice what happens when contempt replaces love, when propaganda replaces honesty, when tribe replaces truth, when fear replaces fellowship, and when power replaces service.

Reality has a way of bearing witness.

And that may be one of the church’s most urgent public tasks now: not to abandon revealed truth, but to learn again how to show that revealed truth corresponds to the world as it really is. To show that God’s commands are not arbitrary religious burdens but descriptions of reality that lead to human flourishing when honored and to breakdown when despised.

In an increasingly intractable political culture, that is no small assignment.

But it is better than surrendering to the lie that our only options are silence, tribalism, or coercion.

There is another way.

Justin calls it compassion and conviction.

I would add: it is what happens when the Curriculum is trusted, the Laboratory is taken seriously, and Christians refuse to let politics become their first discipleship.

That is the work ahead.

And after the landslide, perhaps it matters more than ever.


Sneak Peek

As always, here’s a quick sneak peek at what’s next on Created in the Image of God. And because these conversations may already have aired by the time you read this, they remain available to catch in replay.

On Sunday, November 8 at 7:00 a.m. US Central time, I spoke with Mary Hulst—pastor, preacher, and teacher at Calvin University—about forming faith in a generation shaped by anxiety, social media, and fractured attention, while navigating diverse levels of biblical literacy and Christian experience. It was a thoughtful conversation about the possibilities for a more honest, engaged, and vibrant faith.

Then on Tuesday, November 10 at 8:00 p.m. Central time, I was joined by Paul Copan—philosopher, apologist, and author—to wrestle with some of the hardest moral questions raised by the Old Testament, including divine judgment, wrath, violence, and the consequences of sin. From the moral monster objection to understanding God’s justice and love in difficult texts, it was a rich and challenging exchange.

Share this post