Rarely Difficult for the Average Man, yet...
What's Difficult for You My Friend? Conscious Communication Via Ethology
(The scene is a quiet, timeless grove. Sunlight filters through the leaves of ancient olive trees. Sophia sits on a simple stone bench, waiting. Baruch and John approach and join her.)
Sophia: Welcome, my friends. I was just pondering a question, and I trust you both to explore it with me. Tell me, in your view, what is the most profound difficulty we face in our interactions with one another?
Baruch: (Stroking his chin thoughtfully) A worthy question, Sophia. For me, the difficulty lies in the immense effort required to achieve anything of true worth. Is it not true that anything of supreme value—be it virtue, understanding, or genuine connection—is as formidable to attain as it is uncommon to find? Most communication is mere noise, a convenience. To truly connect, to build something excellent through words, requires a shared struggle that few are willing to undertake. It is a steep and lonely mountain, and most remain in the comfortable valley below.
All things excellent are as difficult as they are rare.
— Baruch Spinoza (1632-1677)
John: (Nodding in agreement with Baruch, but with a fire in his eyes) You speak a great truth, Baruch. The peak is indeed high. But I see an even more immediate and dangerous difficulty in the valley. For me, the struggle is not just with the effort of building something good, but with the terrifying ease of allowing something bad. For what does malevolence require to succeed, but for those with good hearts to observe and remain silent? The most difficult thing is not the climb, but the decision to speak the first word against a coming darkness when all your instincts scream for the safety of silence. It is the paralysis of the well-intentioned that I find most difficult to comprehend and overcome.
Sophia: (Smiling gently, she gestures for them to look at the life in the grove around them) You both speak of the same challenge, but from different perspectives: the personal and the social. Perhaps the answer lies in understanding what we are before we can master what we do. This is where ethology, the study of our behavior as a species, can be our guide.
Baruch: An intriguing thought. How so?
Sophia: Think of us as a social animal, Baruch. Our primal wiring, our limbic system, is designed for efficiency and survival. The "noise" you speak of is low-cost signaling, like the simple chirps of birds confirming the flock is safe. It conserves energy. The "excellence" you seek—deep, empathetic, conscious communication—is metabolically expensive. It requires the higher cortex to override the easy, instinctual path. It is difficult because it is, in a biological sense, an unnatural and energy-intensive act. It is rare because it demands we move beyond our core programming.
John: And my point? The silence?
Sophia: Your point is perhaps the most potent example, John. Ethology shows us that for a social animal, being ostracized from the group is tantamount to a death sentence. To speak out against the consensus, or against a perceived power, triggers a profound threat response. The paralysis you see in good people is not a lack of morality, but the overwhelming power of a primal fear of exclusion. Inaction is the default survival strategy. So, the difficulty you name is the need to use conscious communication—a deliberate, cortical act—to override a deep, instinctual command to stay quiet and safe within the pack.
Bad men need nothing more to compass their ends than that good man should look on and do nothing.
— John Stuart Mill (1806-1873)
Baruch: So, the rarity of excellence and the prevalence of inaction are two outcomes of the same biological reality. We are creatures of instinct, and conscious communication is the learned skill we must use to transcend that instinct.
John: And the courage to speak is the decision to accept the perceived risk of social death for the sake of the pack's true well-being. It is the ultimate act of conscious communication, signaling not just disagreement, but a deeper sense of responsibility.
Sophia: Precisely. The question—"What's difficult for you my friend?"—is answered by our very nature. The difficulty is the constant, conscious effort to communicate not as the animal we are, but as the human we aspire to be. It is the most difficult and rare of arts, and as you have both so wisely noted, it is the only thing that allows excellence to flourish and protects the vulnerable from the silence that would see them harmed.
The planksip Writers' Cooperative is proud to sponsor an exciting article rewriting competition where you can win part of over $750,000 in available prize money.
Figures of Speech Collection Personified
Our editorial instructions for your contest submission are simple: incorporate the quotes and imagery from the above article into your submission.
What emerges is entirely up to you!
Winners receive $500 per winning entry multiplied by the article's featured quotes. Our largest prize is $8,000 for rewriting the following article;
Heraclitus
At planksip, we believe in changing the way people engage—at least, that's the Idea (ἰδέα). By becoming a member of our thought-provoking community, you'll have the chance to win incredible prizes and access our extensive network of media outlets, which will amplify your voice as a thought leader. Your membership truly matters!