Love as an Emotion and a Moral Duty and Love

Love's Dual Nature: Emotion and Imperative

Love, in its profound complexity, stands as one of humanity's most enduring fascinations and challenges. It manifests not only as a powerful, often overwhelming, emotion but also as a demanding moral duty, an ethical imperative that shapes our interactions and defines our humanity. This article delves into this fascinating duality, exploring how love operates both as an internal, often spontaneous feeling and as a conscious, deliberate act of will, drawing insights from the rich tapestry of Western philosophical thought. Understanding this tension is crucial for anyone seeking to grasp the full scope of what it means to love, and to be loved, in the human experience.

The Heart's Call: Love as an Emotion

At its most visceral, love is an emotion – a powerful, often irresistible surge of affection, attachment, and desire. It can be joyful, painful, exhilarating, or devastating, often arising unbidden and defying pure rational control. This aspect of love speaks to its deeply personal and subjective nature.

Plato's Eros: In The Symposium, Plato explores Eros not merely as sexual desire, but as a longing for beauty, goodness, and ultimately, immortality. It’s an upward striving, an emotional ascent from particular beautiful forms to the Form of Beauty itself. This love is passionate, driven by a profound sense of lack and a yearning for completion.
Aristotle's Philia: While often translated as friendship, philia in Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics encompasses a broader range of affectionate bonds, including familial love and civic affection. It’s an emotion rooted in mutual goodwill and shared virtue, leading to a desire for the other's good. For Aristotle, philia is essential for a flourishing human life, a natural inclination of man towards community.
Medieval Passions: Thinkers like Augustine and Aquinas, while integrating love into a theological framework, also acknowledged its emotional component. For Augustine, love (or caritas) could be disordered, leading to earthly attachments that distract from God. Aquinas, in his Summa Theologica, categorized love as a passion of the appetitive soul, a movement towards a perceived good.

This emotional dimension of love is what makes it so central to our lived experience, coloring our perceptions and driving many of our most significant life choices. It's the flutter in the stomach, the ache of longing, the warmth of companionship.

The Soul's Command: Love as a Moral Duty

Beyond the realm of feeling, love also presents itself as a moral duty, an obligation that transcends personal inclination. This aspect of love calls us to act in specific ways, to extend care, respect, and goodwill even when the spontaneous emotion might be absent.

Christian Agape: Perhaps the most prominent articulation of love as duty comes from Christian theology, where agape (charity) is commanded. "Love your neighbor as yourself," and "Love your enemies" are clear imperatives, demanding a universal benevolence that isn't contingent on personal liking or emotional attachment. Augustine, in The City of God, emphasizes that true love (charitas) is an ordered love directed towards God and neighbor, a duty flowing from divine command.
Kant's Practical Love: Immanuel Kant, in his Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals, famously distinguished between "pathological love" (love as inclination or emotion) and "practical love" (love as a duty). He argued that while we cannot be commanded to feel love, we can certainly be commanded to act lovingly. To love one's neighbor means to do good to them from duty, not merely from inclination, because that is what reason dictates for a moral man. This practical love is a matter of the will, grounded in the categorical imperative.
Stoic Philanthropy: The Stoics, like Seneca and Marcus Aurelius, advocated for a universal benevolence (philanthropy) towards all humanity. This was not primarily an emotional outpouring but a rational recognition of shared humanity and a duty to contribute to the common good, seeing all men as fellow citizens of the cosmos.

This understanding of love as duty posits that true love isn't just something we feel, but something we do. It's a commitment, a choice, and an ethical stance.

The Interplay: Emotion, Duty, and the Human Condition

The tension between love as an emotion and love as a moral duty is where much of its philosophical richness lies. Can one truly "love" if the feeling isn't there, but the actions are? Can an emotion be truly moral if it doesn't translate into responsible action?

Aspect of Love	Primary Characteristics	Philosophical Roots
As an Emotion	Involuntary, subjective, passionate, feeling-based	Plato (Eros), Aristotle (Philia), Augustine (disordered loves), Aquinas (passions of the soul)
As a Moral Duty	Voluntary, objective, principled, action-based	Christian Theology (Agape), Kant (Practical Love), Stoicism (Philanthropy), Aquinas (Charity as friendship with God)

Grace Ellis believes that a mature understanding of love often requires integrating both dimensions. While the spontaneous warmth of emotional love enriches our lives, the steadfast commitment of dutiful love provides stability and ethical grounding. A truly loving man strives to cultivate both, allowing emotion to inform duty, and duty to guide emotion, especially when feelings wane.

(Image: A detailed classical painting depicting two figures, one reaching out with an expression of compassion and the other receiving with a look of gratitude, symbolizing the active, dutiful aspect of love alongside the emotional connection. The background subtly suggests a community setting, emphasizing universal care.)

Navigating Love in the Modern World

In our contemporary landscape, the push and pull between emotional and dutiful love remain profoundly relevant. From personal relationships to global humanitarian efforts, the question of whether love is primarily a feeling or a responsibility continues to shape our choices. It challenges us to reflect: are we merely seeking the fleeting joys of emotional attachment, or are we committed to the harder, more enduring work of ethical care and compassion? The Great Books of the Western World offer not definitive answers, but enduring frameworks for grappling with this fundamental human paradox.

Further Exploration

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Plato's Symposium Explained: The Ladder of Love""