Love as an Emotion and a Moral Duty and Love

The Dual Nature of Love: Passionate Impulse and Moral Imperative

Love, in its profound complexity, stands as one of the most compelling and perplexing phenomena in the human experience. It is simultaneously a tempestuous emotion that sweeps over us, an unbidden guest in the heart, and a solemn duty, a conscious commitment that demands unwavering resolve from Man. This article delves into this fascinating duality, exploring how classical philosophical thought, particularly as found in the Great Books of the Western World, illuminates love's spontaneous, affective dimensions alongside its rational, ethical obligations. We will navigate the tension and synergy between these aspects, ultimately seeking to understand how Man can cultivate a love that is both deeply felt and morally robust.

Love's Emotional Heartbeat: The Unbidden Flame

At its core, love often manifests first as a powerful emotion. It is the surge of affection, the pang of longing, the profound sense of connection that arises, often unexpectedly, towards another person, a community, or even an ideal. This aspect of love is characterized by its spontaneity, its subjective intensity, and its capacity to both elevate and devastate the human spirit.

Plato's Eros: In Plato’s Symposium, Eros is depicted not merely as carnal desire, but as a divine madness, a longing for beauty and goodness itself. It is an emotion that propels the soul upwards, from the love of a beautiful body to the love of beautiful souls, then to beautiful customs, knowledge, and ultimately, to the Form of Beauty. This is an ecstatic, passionate love, driven by an inherent lack and a yearning for completion. It is a powerful, almost involuntary force that shapes Man's aspirations.
Aristotle's Philia: While distinct from Plato's Eros, Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, explores philia, often translated as friendship or affection. This too is an emotion, albeit a more stable and reciprocal one, based on shared virtue or utility. It is a feeling of goodwill and companionship that enriches Man's life and fosters community. This affective bond, while perhaps less volatile than Eros, is undeniably rooted in feeling and mutual regard.

This emotional dimension of love highlights its power to move us, to inspire great acts of devotion, and to shape our personal relationships. It is the part of love that we "fall into," often without conscious decision.

The Weight of Obligation: Love as a Moral Duty

Beyond the realm of spontaneous feeling, love frequently presents itself as a moral duty, a commitment that transcends mere inclination. This aspect of love is volitional, rational, and often demands sacrifice and perseverance, irrespective of fluctuating emotions. It is a choice, an obligation that Man undertakes.

Kantian Duty: Immanuel Kant, a towering figure in ethical philosophy, provides a stark contrast to purely emotional love. For Kant, a truly moral act is one performed out of duty to the moral law, not out of inclination or feeling. While he acknowledged that feeling love for humanity is good, he argued that genuine moral worth comes from acting as if one loves, even when the emotion is absent. To love one's neighbor, for Kant, is not merely to feel affection, but to consistently act in ways that uphold their dignity and well-being, because it is one's rational duty to do so. This is a love commanded by reason, a categorical imperative for Man.
Christian Agape: Within the Great Books, particularly in theological texts like those of St. Augustine and St. Thomas Aquinas, agape emerges as a profound form of dutiful love. Agape is often understood as unconditional, self-sacrificial love that seeks the good of the other, irrespective of their merit or our feelings towards them. It is a divine command, a duty enjoined upon Man by God. Augustine, in Confessions and City of God, speaks of loving God and neighbor not merely as an emotion, but as the highest expression of the will, a duty to order one's loves rightly. Aquinas, in Summa Theologica, further elaborates on charity as a theological virtue, a love that is willed and enacted for the sake of the beloved, ultimately rooted in the love of God.

This dutiful dimension emphasizes the ethical responsibility inherent in love, transforming it from a passive experience into an active, conscious commitment.

The Intertwined Path: Reconciling Emotion and Duty

The greatest philosophical challenge lies in understanding how these two facets of love—the spontaneous emotion and the deliberate duty—coexist and ideally, coalesce. Is a love without feeling truly love? Can a purely emotional love be morally sustainable?

The journey of Man often involves navigating this complex terrain. A purely emotional love, while exhilarating, can be fickle and transient, vulnerable to changing moods and circumstances. A purely dutiful love, while steadfast and morally upright, might risk feeling cold or impersonal, lacking the warmth and vitality that makes love truly human.

Many thinkers suggest that the most complete form of love integrates both. Man is called not only to feel love but also to will it, to cultivate the affections and to act in accordance with the principles of care and respect. The emotion can inspire the duty, providing the passion and energy needed to sustain commitment. The duty, in turn, provides the structure, resilience, and ethical grounding that allows love to endure and flourish even when feelings wane.

Consider the following comparison:

Aspect of Love	Emotional Love	Dutiful Love
Nature	Spontaneous, affective, inclination	Volitional, rational, obligation
Source	Feelings, desires, attractions	Moral reason, principles, will
Philosophers	Plato (Eros), Aristotle (Philia), Romantics	Kant, Stoics, Christian Ethics (Augustine, Aquinas)
Focus	Subjective experience, personal attachment	Objective good, universal principles, action
Sustainability	Potentially fleeting, dependent on feeling	Stable, consistent, independent of mood
Keyword Link	Emotion	Duty
Man's Role	Experiencing, being moved	Choosing, acting, committing

Generated Image

Cultivating a Complete Love

For Man, the aspiration is not to choose between emotion and duty, but to integrate them. This involves:

Awareness of Feelings: Recognizing and understanding the powerful emotions that love evokes, allowing them to enrich our experience and motivate our actions.
Commitment to Principles: Upholding the moral duty to love through acts of kindness, justice, and self-sacrifice, even when it is difficult or inconvenient.
Volitional Nurturing: Actively choosing to cultivate both the emotion and the duty. This means not only allowing oneself to feel but also consciously acting in loving ways, which can, in turn, deepen emotional bonds.

The Great Books of the Western World consistently present love as a foundational element of human flourishing and ethical living. From the passionate yearnings of Plato's lover to Kant's rigorous moral agent, the narrative underscores that love, in its fullest expression, requires both the unbidden beat of the heart and the deliberate resolve of the will. It is in this dynamic interplay that Man truly understands and lives out the profound power of love.