Justice as the Virtue of the State: A Classical Imperative

The concept of justice, particularly as it pertains to the state, is a cornerstone of political philosophy, deeply explored within the Great Books of the Western World. From the ancient Greek polis to the modern nation-state, thinkers have grappled with the idea that a state’s legitimacy, purpose, and very essence are inextricably linked to its capacity for justice. This article explores how philosophers, notably Plato and Aristotle, established justice not merely as a desirable attribute, but as the fundamental virtue of the state, sustained and expressed through its laws, and standing in stark opposition to the myriad forms of vice that threaten societal flourishing.

The Platonic Ideal: A State in Harmonious Virtue

In Plato's seminal work, The Republic, the philosopher presents a profound analogy between the individual soul and the state. Just as a just individual achieves harmony when their rational, spirited, and appetitive parts function correctly under the guidance of reason, so too does a just state achieve internal balance when its distinct classes perform their designated roles without interference. For Plato, Justice is this condition of internal harmony and proper functioning, making it the supreme Virtue of the State.

  • The Tripartite State: Plato envisions a state divided into three classes, each mirroring a part of the soul:
    • Guardians (Rulers): Possessing wisdom, they govern the state.
    • Auxiliaries (Warriors): Exhibiting courage, they protect the state.
    • Producers (Artisans/Farmers): Demonstrating temperance, they provide for the state's material needs.

In this ideal state, Law is the instrument through which this harmony is maintained. Just laws ensure that the guardians, guided by reason and philosophical insight, legislate for the common good, preventing any class from overstepping its bounds. When this order breaks down, when any part fails to perform its specific function or seeks to usurp the role of another, the state descends into Vice, leading to injustice and instability, such as oligarchy, democracy, or tyranny.

Platonic State Class Corresponding Soul Part Primary Virtue Function in the State
Guardians (Rulers) Rational Wisdom Govern, legislate
Auxiliaries (Warriors) Spirited Courage Defend, enforce
Producers (Workers) Appetitive Temperance Provide, sustain

Aristotle's Practical Wisdom: Justice in Action within the Polis

Aristotle, in his Politics and Nicomachean Ethics, further elaborates on the concept of justice, viewing the State (the polis) as a natural association formed for the sake of the "good life"—a life of human flourishing or eudaimonia. For Aristotle, Justice is not merely a component of the state, but the complete Virtue, encompassing all other virtues in relation to others.

Aristotle distinguishes between several forms of justice:

  • Distributive Justice: Concerned with the fair allocation of honors, wealth, and other goods among citizens according to merit or contribution. The Law must ensure equitable distribution, not necessarily equal, but proportionate.
  • Corrective Justice: Aims to rectify wrongs and restore balance when an injustice has occurred, typically through the legal system (e.g., punishment for crimes, compensation for damages).
  • Reciprocal Justice: Pertaining to fair exchange in transactions.

For Aristotle, the Law is crucial for establishing and maintaining justice. A just legal framework is one that aims at the common good, fostering civic Virtue among citizens. The State, through its Laws, provides the environment in which individuals can develop their moral and intellectual capacities, thus achieving the good life. Conversely, a state governed by unjust laws, or one where rulers act solely for their own benefit, embodies Vice and fails in its fundamental purpose.

The Enduring Legacy: Justice, Law, and the Modern State

The profound insights of Plato and Aristotle laid the groundwork for subsequent philosophical inquiries into the nature of the State and its relationship to Justice. While later thinkers in the Great Books tradition, such as Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau, approached the origins and legitimacy of the state through concepts like the social contract, the underlying imperative for justice remained central. Hobbes' Leviathan, for instance, justifies its absolute power by preventing the ultimate vice of chaos and ensuring security, a form of rudimentary justice. Locke’s natural rights theory posits that the state's primary function and its Laws are to protect these inherent rights, thereby upholding a fundamental form of justice.

The continuous dialogue across centuries affirms that the pursuit of Justice through the establishment of just Laws is not merely an optional aspiration but the defining Virtue that legitimizes and sustains any political entity. The struggle against Vice in governance—corruption, tyranny, inequality—is a timeless testament to the enduring human quest for a state that truly serves the good of its citizens.

(Image: A detailed allegorical painting depicting Lady Justice, blindfolded, holding scales in one hand and a sword in the other, standing firmly on a pedestal. At her feet, various figures representing different aspects of society (e.g., a philosopher, a merchant, a common citizen) look up to her, symbolizing the state's role in upholding impartial justice for all its constituents. The background features classical architecture, suggesting the ancient origins of the concept.)

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Plato Republic Justice State"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Aristotle Politics Justice Law"

Share this post