Justice as the Virtue of the State: A Chloe Fitzgerald Perspective

Summary: The concept of a just state is not merely an idealistic aspiration but, as ancient philosophers posited, the very essence of a well-ordered and flourishing society. This article explores how Justice functions as the cardinal Virtue of the State, examining its historical foundations, its embodiment in Law, and the constant struggle against Vice to maintain collective well-being. From Plato's ideal republic to modern social contracts, the pursuit of state justice remains paramount for human flourishing.

The Soul of the Polis: Why Justice Matters for the State

For centuries, thinkers have grappled with the fundamental question: what makes a good society? While individual virtues like courage and wisdom are celebrated, the collective character of a nation, its very "soul," hinges on something more profound: justice. As I see it, justice is not just one virtue among many for a state; it is the virtue, the organizing principle that allows all other goods to flourish. Without it, even the most prosperous society risks descending into chaos and tyranny.

Our journey into this concept begins in the fertile grounds of ancient Greece, where the relationship between the individual and the collective was meticulously explored. The philosophers of the Great Books of the Western World laid the groundwork for understanding how justice, far from being an abstract ideal, is woven into the very fabric of governance and civil life.

Plato's Republic: Justice as Functional Harmony

Perhaps no one articulated the state's virtue of justice more profoundly than Plato in his seminal work, The Republic. For Plato, justice in the state is a mirror image of justice in the individual soul. Just as the individual soul achieves justice when its three parts—reason, spirit, and appetite—are in proper balance and each performs its function, so too does the state.

Plato envisioned an ideal State composed of three classes:

  1. Guardians (Rulers): Guided by wisdom (reason), they govern.
  2. Auxiliaries (Warriors): Possessing courage (spirit), they protect.
  3. Producers (Artisans/Farmers): Exercising temperance (appetite), they provide for material needs.

(Image: An ancient Greek fresco depicting Plato conversing with students in a serene academy setting, with scrolls and philosophical instruments scattered around, symbolizing the pursuit of knowledge and the foundations of political theory.)

Justice, in this Platonic sense, is achieved when each class performs its proper function without interfering with the others. It is the harmonious arrangement where everyone does what they are naturally best suited for, contributing to the common good. Any deviation, any class overstepping its bounds, introduces vice and disorder, undermining the state's integrity. This structural integrity, maintained by wise governance and adherence to appropriate roles, is the very definition of a just state for Plato.

Aristotle and the Pursuit of the Common Good through Law

While Plato sought an ideal, Aristotle, his student, grounded the discussion of justice more firmly in the practicalities of the polis (city-state). For Aristotle, the State exists for the sake of the good life, and Law is the primary instrument through which this good life, and thus justice, is achieved.

Aristotle distinguished between different forms of justice:

Type of Justice Description Application in the State
Distributive Justice Concerns the fair allocation of honors, wealth, and other goods based on merit. The state, through its laws, must ensure that citizens receive what they are due according to their contributions or needs, avoiding arbitrary favoritism or discrimination (a form of vice).
Corrective Justice Aims to rectify wrongs and restore balance in transactions or disputes. The judicial system, through law, punishes criminals and resolves civil disputes, ensuring that victims are compensated and offenders are held accountable, thus preventing further vice.

For Aristotle, a just State is one governed by Law that aims at the common good, not merely the good of a ruling faction. When Law is applied impartially and consistently, it cultivates virtue among citizens and prevents the spread of vice. The Law itself, when crafted thoughtfully and justly, becomes a teacher of civic virtue, guiding individuals towards ethical conduct necessary for a flourishing community.

Modern Perspectives: The Social Contract and the Rule of Law

Moving beyond antiquity, the Enlightenment philosophers expanded upon the idea of state justice, particularly through the lens of the social contract. Thinkers like Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau, despite their differences, agreed that the State derives its legitimacy from the consent of the governed, primarily to establish and maintain order and justice.

  • Hobbes saw the state as a necessary leviathan to escape the brutal "state of nature," where life was "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short." Here, justice is simply adherence to the sovereign's law, which alone can prevent the vice of anarchy.
  • Locke argued for a state whose primary role is to protect individual natural rights—life, liberty, and property—through established laws. A just state, for Locke, respects these rights and operates under the rule of law, not arbitrary power.
  • Rousseau emphasized the "general will," where laws are expressions of the collective good, and obedience to these self-imposed laws is true freedom and the hallmark of a just society.

In these modern interpretations, the Law becomes the tangible manifestation of the state's commitment to justice. It codifies rights, establishes duties, and provides mechanisms for redress. A state that fails to uphold the Rule of Law, where laws are unequally applied or serve only a select few, inherently succumbs to vice and loses its claim to virtue.

The Ongoing Struggle: Cultivating Virtue, Combating Vice

The ideal of justice as the virtue of the state is not a destination but a continuous journey. Even in democratic societies, the pursuit of justice is a dynamic process, fraught with challenges. The state must constantly strive to:

  • Uphold the Rule of Law: Ensuring that laws are clear, consistent, and applied impartially to all, regardless of status or power.
  • Promote Equity: Addressing systemic inequalities that prevent certain groups from fully participating in or benefiting from society's goods.
  • Ensure Accountability: Holding those in power responsible for their actions, preventing corruption and the abuse of authority (forms of vice).
  • Protect Rights: Safeguarding the fundamental liberties and dignities of all citizens.
  • Foster Civic Virtue: Encouraging active, informed participation from citizens, who themselves must cultivate virtues like integrity, empathy, and respect for others.

When a state veers into corruption, cronyism, or oppression, it embodies vice. Its laws become tools of tyranny rather than instruments of justice. The state's virtue is directly proportional to its commitment to these principles, reflecting a constant vigilance against the forces that seek to undermine fairness and order.

Conclusion: The Indispensable Virtue

In closing, the concept of justice as the virtue of the state remains as relevant today as it was in the ancient polis. From Plato's vision of functional harmony to Aristotle's emphasis on law for the common good, and through the Enlightenment's social contracts, the message is clear: a state's true strength and legitimacy derive from its commitment to justice. It is the bedrock upon which human flourishing is built, the constant goal that allows societies to navigate the complexities of collective life, and the enduring standard against which all forms of governance must ultimately be measured. To pursue justice in the state is to pursue the highest form of collective virtue, and to neglect it is to invite vice and decay.

YouTube: Plato's Republic Justice State
YouTube: Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Justice Law

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Justice as the Virtue of the State philosophy"

Share this post