Justice as the Virtue of the State

When we speak of Justice, our minds often conjure images of courts, scales, or perhaps an individual's moral rectitude. However, the ancient philosophers, particularly those whose wisdom is preserved in the Great Books of the Western World, understood Justice not merely as an individual trait, but as the supreme virtue that defines and sustains the State itself. This article delves into how thinkers like Plato and Aristotle articulated Justice as the foundational principle for a well-ordered society, exploring its interplay with Virtue and Vice, and the indispensable role of Law.

The Platonic Ideal: Harmony in the Polis

For Plato, as meticulously laid out in his Republic, Justice in the State is a mirror image of Justice in the individual soul. He posited that just as the individual soul achieves harmony when its rational, spirited, and appetitive parts function correctly under the guidance of reason, so too does the State achieve Justice when its distinct classes perform their designated roles without encroaching upon others.

Plato's ideal State comprises three primary classes, each embodying a specific virtue:

  • Rulers (Guardians): Possessing wisdom, they govern with reason and foresight, akin to the rational part of the soul.
  • Auxiliaries (Soldiers): Embodying courage, they protect the State, representing the spirited part of the soul.
  • Producers (Craftsmen, Farmers): Exercising temperance (self-control), they provide for the material needs of society, mirroring the appetitive part.

Justice, in this framework, is not a separate virtue but the overarching principle that ensures each class "minds its own business" and performs its function optimally. It is the virtue of proper arrangement and harmony. When these parts fall out of sync, when, for instance, the appetitive class seeks to rule, the State descends into vice, exhibiting tyranny, oligarchy, or democracy in its corrupt forms, leading to instability and injustice. The Law, though not the primary focus for Plato in creating the ideal State, serves to uphold this divinely inspired order once established.

Aristotle's Pragmatic Lens: Justice and the Rule of Law

Aristotle, Plato's most famous student, approached Justice with a more empirical and practical perspective in his Nicomachean Ethics and Politics. While acknowledging the importance of virtue, Aristotle focused on Justice as a matter of fairness, proportionality, and adherence to Law within the existing State.

He distinguished between several forms of Justice:

  • Distributive Justice: Concerned with the fair allocation of honors, wealth, and other goods among citizens according to merit or contribution. This prevents the vice of inequality where it is undeserved.
  • Corrective Justice: Aims to rectify wrongs and restore balance in transactions, whether voluntary (contracts) or involuntary (crimes). It ensures that individuals are treated equally before the Law, compensating for loss or punishing transgression.
  • Political Justice: The overarching framework within the State that encompasses both distributive and corrective aspects, guided by Law.

For Aristotle, the State exists to enable its citizens to achieve eudaimonia, or human flourishing. A just State is one where the Law is sovereign, ensuring that citizens live virtuously and are treated fairly. Law is not merely a set of rules but the embodiment of reason, guiding the State away from vice and towards the common good. When rulers govern according to Law and in the interest of all, the State exhibits Justice. When they govern in their own interest, or disregard the Law, the State becomes corrupt and unjust.

The Interplay of Virtue, State, and Law

Both Plato and Aristotle, despite their differing emphases, converge on the idea that Justice is the essential virtue for the State's health and longevity. It is the bedrock upon which all other societal virtues can flourish and the bulwark against the destructive forces of vice.

Here's a synthesis of their insights into the characteristics of a just State:

  • Order and Harmony: A just State is well-ordered, with each part or citizen fulfilling their proper function.
  • Rule of Law: Justice is enshrined and enforced through equitable Laws that apply to all, including rulers.
  • Common Good: The State's actions and Laws are directed towards the welfare and flourishing of all citizens, not just a select few.
  • Merit and Fairness: Resources and opportunities are distributed fairly, and wrongs are corrected impartially.
  • Cultivation of Virtue: A just State fosters an environment where citizens can develop individual virtues like wisdom, courage, and temperance.

(Image: A detailed classical Greek fresco depicting a council of elders or philosophers debating in an agora, with citizens listening attentively, symbolizing the pursuit of collective wisdom and just governance in the ancient polis.)

The absence of Justice inevitably leads to vice within the State: corruption, factionalism, tyranny, and ultimately, collapse. The Law, therefore, is not merely a regulatory tool but a moral instrument, designed to guide the State towards its highest virtue – Justice.

Enduring Relevance

The profound insights of these ancient philosophers continue to resonate. The quest for a just State remains a central political and ethical challenge. Understanding Justice not just as an abstract ideal but as the animating virtue of the collective body politic, maintained through thoughtful Law and the commitment of its citizens, is as crucial today as it was in the Athenian polis. It reminds us that the health of our societies hinges on our collective dedication to this fundamental virtue.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Plato's Republic Justice State"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Aristotle Politics Justice Law Virtue"

Share this post