Justice as the Virtue of the State and Justice

Justice as the Virtue of the State: A Classical Inquiry

From the ancient agora to the modern parliament, the question of justice has perpetually haunted the halls of power. It is not merely a legal concept or a social construct, but, as the great thinkers of the Western tradition have argued, the very essence of a well-ordered state. This article explores the profound idea that justice is not just a virtue, but the cardinal virtue of the state, examining how classical philosophy, particularly from the Great Books of the Western World, posits justice as the fundamental principle for societal flourishing, delineating the boundaries between virtue and vice in governance, and establishing the indispensable role of law.

The Platonic Ideal: Justice as Harmony

Plato, in his seminal work The Republic, crafts an intricate vision where justice in the state mirrors justice in the individual soul. For Plato, a just state is one where each part performs its proper function without interfering with others. He envisions a tripartite society:

• Guardians (Rulers): Possessing wisdom, they govern with foresight and reason.
• Auxiliaries (Warriors): Exhibiting courage, they protect the state.
• Producers (Workers): Demonstrating temperance, they provide for material needs.

When these three classes operate in harmony, guided by wisdom and bound by a common purpose, the state achieves justice. This is not merely an absence of conflict, but a positive, active state of balance and right ordering. Any deviation from this harmonious arrangement, where one part oversteps its bounds or fails in its duty, leads to injustice and ultimately, the decay of the state into various forms of vice such as oligarchy, democracy (in its corrupt form), or tyranny. The just state, therefore, is a virtuous one, characterized by internal order and external righteousness.

Aristotle's Pragmatism: The State as a Means to Virtue

While Plato sought an ideal, Aristotle, in his Politics and Nicomachean Ethics, grounded his philosophy in observation and the practical realities of human communities. For Aristotle, the state (or polis) is a natural institution, existing not merely for the sake of living, but for the sake of living well. He argues that humans are "political animals," whose highest potential can only be realized within a well-ordered community.

Justice, for Aristotle, is the "complete virtue in relation to another." It is not just about individual righteousness but about fairness in distribution (distributive justice) and rectification of wrongs (rectificatory justice) within the community. The law becomes the primary instrument through which this justice is instantiated.

Key aspects of Aristotelian justice in the state include:

• Distributive Justice: Fair allocation of honors, wealth, and other goods according to merit or contribution.
• Rectificatory Justice: Correcting imbalances, such as in contracts or criminal acts, to restore equality.
• Political Justice: The framework of laws and customs that govern the interactions between citizens, aiming for the common good.

Aristotle believed that a state whose laws are just and whose rulers govern for the benefit of all citizens cultivates virtue and leads to eudaimonia, or human flourishing. Conversely, a state governed by self-interest, where vice predominates, fails in its fundamental purpose.

Law as the Embodiment of Justice

Both Plato and Aristotle, despite their differences, underscore the critical role of law in manifesting justice. For Plato, while the philosopher-king ideally transcends the need for rigid laws, in practical states, laws serve as imperfect but necessary guides, reflecting the principles of the ideal. For Aristotle, law is the "reason unaffected by desire," providing an impartial standard for conduct.

The law in a just state serves several vital functions:

1. Establishes Order: It provides a predictable framework for social interaction, preventing chaos.
2. Protects Rights: It safeguards individuals from harm and ensures fair treatment.
3. Promotes Virtue: It can encourage virtuous behavior and discourage vice through its prohibitions and incentives.
4. Resolves Disputes: It offers a mechanism for impartial arbitration and resolution of conflicts.
5. Limits Power: It constrains the actions of rulers, preventing tyranny and arbitrary rule.

When the law itself is just, reflecting principles of fairness and the common good, it becomes the backbone of a virtuous state. When laws are arbitrary, oppressive, or serve only the interests of a select few, they become instruments of injustice, fostering vice and undermining the legitimacy of the state.

Virtue and Vice in Governance

The classical understanding of justice as the virtue of the state inherently links the character of its rulers and citizens to its overall well-being. A state is not merely a collection of institutions; it is a reflection of the moral fiber of its people.

• Virtuous Governance: Rulers who embody wisdom, courage, temperance, and above all, justice, are essential. Their actions, guided by reason and a commitment to the common good, foster trust and stability. This leads to a virtuous cycle where just governance encourages virtuous citizenry.
• Vicious Governance: Conversely, when rulers are driven by self-interest, greed, fear, or ambition, they succumb to vice. This leads to corruption, tyranny, and the erosion of public trust. Such states are inherently unstable, prone to internal strife and external weakness, as they deviate from the true purpose of the state: to enable human flourishing through justice.

The enduring lesson from the Great Books of the Western World is that the pursuit of justice is not an optional embellishment for the state, but its foundational imperative. It is the very measure of its legitimacy and its capacity to serve its citizens.

Conclusion: The Timeless Pursuit

The classical philosophical tradition unequivocally positions justice as the paramount virtue of the state. From Plato’s harmonious republic to Aristotle’s practical polis, the message is clear: a state that fails to embody justice in its structures, laws, and governance inevitably succumbs to vice and falls short of its potential to foster human flourishing. This ancient wisdom remains profoundly relevant, urging us to continuously examine whether our contemporary states truly embody this foundational virtue, striving for governance that is not merely efficient, but fundamentally just.

📹 Related Video: PLATO ON: The Allegory of the Cave

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Plato's Republic Justice State" and "Aristotle Politics Justice Law""