Desire as the Root: Unpacking Sin's Ancient Pedigree

A Montgomery Meditation on Humanity's Perpetual Struggle

From the whispers of ancient philosophers to the thunderous pronouncements of theologians, a persistent theme echoes through the annals of Western thought: Desire stands as the fundamental cause of Sin. This isn't merely about carnal lust, but a far broader concept encompassing every human craving that, when unchecked or misdirected, leads us astray from wisdom, virtue, or divine law. It is in the intricate dance between our inherent longings and the choices of our Will that the very fabric of human transgression is woven. This article delves into how the great minds, from Plato to Augustine, illuminated desire's potent, often perilous, role in our moral landscape.

At its core, sin can be understood as a deviation from an ideal, a moral failing, or an act contrary to divine or natural law. But what causes such a deviation? While external temptations play a role, the profound thinkers of the Great Books of the Western World consistently point inwards, to the wellspring of human motivation: desire. It is not desire itself that is inherently evil, for many desires are natural and necessary for life. Rather, it is the disordered desire – the longing for something inappropriate, inordinate, or at the expense of a greater good – that plants the seed of sin.

(Image: A classical Greek marble bust of a contemplative philosopher, perhaps Plato or Aristotle, with an intense, focused gaze, suggesting deep thought on human nature and ethics. The background is softly blurred, implying the timelessness of philosophical inquiry.)

Anatomy of Desire: From Appetites to Aspiration

To understand desire as the cause of sin, we must first understand desire itself.

What is Desire?

  • Platonic & Aristotelian View: Desire (epithymia, orexis) is a fundamental part of the soul, encompassing appetites for bodily pleasures (food, drink, sex), but also for honor, knowledge, and even immortality. For Plato, the appetitive part of the soul, if not guided by reason (logos) and spirit (thumos), can lead to intemperance and injustice. Aristotle, too, recognized desires as impulses towards perceived goods, which must be moderated by virtue.
  • Augustinian View: Augustine delves deeper into a disordered desire, particularly after the Fall. He speaks of libido – not just sexual lust, but a broader "lust for domination" (libido dominandi), a craving for earthly goods, power, or self-gratification that turns the Will away from God, the ultimate good. This turning is the very essence of sin.
  • Aquinian View: Thomas Aquinas, building on Aristotle and Augustine, identifies concupiscence as the rebellion of the lower appetites against the dictates of reason. This inclination towards sensible goods, when it overrides rational judgment and the Will's proper orientation, becomes a potent cause of sin.

The common thread is clear: when desire becomes excessive, misdirected, or prioritizes a lesser good over a greater one, it sets the stage for moral transgression.

The Will's Predicament: Desire's Influence on Choice

The crucial link between desire and sin is forged in the forge of the Will. Is the will a helpless victim of desire, or does it possess the power to resist?

The Interplay of Desire and Will

Philosophical Perspective Role of Desire Role of Will Outcome for Sin
Plato Appetites, if unbridled, pull the soul away from reason. Reason's role is to guide and control appetites. Sin (injustice, intemperance) occurs when reason fails to govern desire.
Aristotle Natural impulses towards perceived goods. The Will (prohairesis) makes a deliberate choice based on deliberation. Sin (vice) is a result of choosing to indulge excessive or deficient desires, rather than the virtuous mean.
Augustine Disordered desire (concupiscence) corrupts the will, making it prone to choose lesser goods. The Will is free, but wounded by original sin; it chooses to turn away from God, often swayed by intense desires. Sin is fundamentally a choice of the Will to pursue self-love over divine love, influenced by disordered desires.
Aquinas Concupiscence inclines the sensitive appetite away from reason. The Will remains free to choose, even if it feels the pull of disordered desires. It can assent or dissent. Sin occurs when the Will freely chooses to follow a disordered desire, contradicting reason and divine law.

In essence, while desire provides the impetus, the Will makes the ultimate decision. It is the Will's assent to a disordered desire that fully actualizes the sin. The cause is not just the presence of desire, but the Will's failure to master it, to align it with reason or divine purpose.

The Pathways of Transgression: How Desire Manifests as Sin

Consider how various forms of desire become the direct cause of specific sins:

  • Desire for Material Possessions: Can lead to avarice, theft, greed, envy. The insatiable longing for more, often beyond need, pushes individuals to transgress ethical boundaries.
  • Desire for Power and Control: Fuels ambition, pride, tyranny, injustice. The libido dominandi Augustine spoke of, where one seeks to subjugate others or assert self-will above all, is a potent source of evil.
  • Desire for Bodily Pleasure: Can manifest as gluttony, lust, intemperance. When these natural appetites become ends in themselves, divorced from reason or proper context, they lead to excess and moral decay.
  • Desire for Recognition/Glory: Can lead to vanity, boastfulness, hypocrisy. Seeking external validation above truth or genuine virtue.

In each instance, the initial desire – a natural human impulse – becomes the cause of sin when it is pursued without moderation, reason, or a higher moral compass, overwhelming the Will's capacity for right choice.

Conclusion: The Enduring Battle Within

The study of desire as the primary cause of sin reveals a profound and enduring truth about the human condition: our moral struggles are often internal. The great minds of the Western tradition, from the rationalists of ancient Greece to the theologians of the medieval era, consistently highlighted the internal struggle to manage our appetites and aspirations. It is not merely the presence of desire, but its direction, its intensity, and, crucially, the Will's response to it, that determines our moral trajectory. Understanding this ancient wisdom is the first step in mastering the self and navigating the treacherous waters where desire can so easily lead to sin.

YouTube Video Suggestions:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Augustine Confessions Free Will Sin"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Plato Aristotle Desire Ethics Virtue"

Share this post