The Serpent's Whisper: Desire as the Cause of Sin

Summary: Across the vast panorama of Western thought, from ancient Greece to the scholastic heights of the Middle Ages, a persistent theme emerges: desire, often unbridled or misdirected, stands as the fundamental cause of sin. This article explores how philosophers and theologians within the Great Books of the Western World tradition articulate the intricate relationship between our innate urges, the choices of our will, and the genesis of morally transgressive acts, defining sin not merely as a religious concept but as any deviation from reason, virtue, or a higher good.

The Primal Urge: Defining Desire and Sin

At the heart of the human condition lies desire—an intrinsic longing, an impulse towards something perceived as good or pleasurable. It is the engine of ambition, love, and creativity. However, when this powerful force becomes disordered, unchecked, or aims at an inappropriate object, it often precipitates what we term sin. For our purposes, sin can be understood broadly as any act, thought, or omission that violates a moral law, a divine commandment, or a principle of virtue, leading to harm, injustice, or a falling short of one's potential. The crucial philosophical inquiry then becomes: how does this internal drive, this desire, transform into the cause of such transgressions?

The Interplay of Desire, Will, and Cause

The journey from desire to sin is rarely a simple, direct path. It involves the complex machinery of the human psyche, prominently featuring the will. While desire may present the temptation, it is often the will—our faculty of choice and decision—that ultimately consents to or rejects the impulse, thereby determining whether a desire remains an inclination or manifests as a sinful act. Understanding this dynamic is key to grasping how desire functions as the cause. It isn't always a direct compulsion, but rather an powerful antecedent, an allurement that sways the will.

Philosophical Perspectives from the Great Books

The notion that desire is a primary cause of sin finds profound articulation in various seminal texts, each offering a unique lens through which to examine this complex relationship.

Plato and the Tripartite Soul

In Plato's Republic, the human soul is famously divided into three parts:

  • Reason (Logistikon): Seeks truth and wisdom.
  • Spirit (Thymoeides): Seeks honor and victory, allied with reason.
  • Appetite (Epithymia): Seeks bodily pleasures and material possessions (food, drink, sex, wealth). This is the seat of desire.

For Plato, sin (or injustice/vice) arises when the appetitive part of the soul, driven by its insatiable desires, overwhelms reason and spirit. The ideal state is one where reason, like a charioteer, skillfully guides and controls the spirited and appetitive horses. When the appetites run wild, pursuing excessive pleasure or material gain, they lead the individual away from virtue and into actions that are unjust and harmful, thus making unchecked desire a direct cause of moral failing.

Aristotle on Virtue and Excess

Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, approaches the problem through the lens of virtue as a mean between two extremes. He acknowledges that desires for pleasure, wealth, or honor are natural. However, sin (or vice) occurs when these desires are pursued to excess or deficiency. For instance:

  • Courage: The mean between cowardice (deficient desire to face danger) and rashness (excessive desire to face danger).
  • Temperance: The mean regarding bodily pleasures. Intemperance, a clear sin in his view, is the result of an excessive desire for sensual gratification.

Aristotle posits that the will (prohairesis) makes choices based on deliberation, but desires can heavily influence this deliberation, making it difficult for the will to choose the virtuous mean. Thus, disordered desire can lead the will astray, becoming a cause of vice.

Augustine of Hippo: Concupiscence and the Fallen Will

For Augustine, particularly in works like Confessions and City of God, the link between desire and sin is profoundly theological and existential. He introduces the concept of concupiscence, which he defines as the "disordered desire of the soul for earthly goods." After the Fall, human nature became corrupted, and the will, though still free, became enslaved by these disordered desires.

Augustine argues that the will chooses evil not because evil is inherently appealing, but because it is swayed by a lesser good presented by disordered desire, turning away from the ultimate Good (God). The will is weak, easily enticed by the allure of the flesh, pride, and avarice—all manifestations of desire. Here, desire is not just an inclination but a powerful, almost coercive force that, when consented to by the will, becomes the direct cause of sin.

Thomas Aquinas and the Passions

Thomas Aquinas, in the Summa Theologica, synthesizes Aristotelian philosophy with Christian theology. He categorizes desires as "passions of the soul," which are movements of the sensitive appetite (e.g., love, hate, joy, sorrow, hope, fear). Aquinas states that these passions are morally neutral in themselves. However, they become good or evil depending on whether they are ordered by reason and the will.

Sin occurs when the will consents to a passion that is contrary to reason and the divine law. For Aquinas, the will is the master of its own acts, but the passions can incline the will to act in certain ways. If the will freely chooses to follow a disordered desire against the dictates of reason, then sin is committed. Thus, desire acts as an antecedent cause, presenting the object, but the will's consent is the proximate cause of the sinful act itself.

Table: Key Thinkers on Desire, Will, and Sin

Philosopher/Theologian Concept of Desire Role of Will How Desire Causes Sin
Plato Appetites (Epithymia), bodily pleasures Reason must control Unchecked appetites overpower reason, leading to injustice/vice.
Aristotle Natural urges for pleasure, wealth, honor Chooses the mean; influenced by deliberation Excess or deficiency in satisfying desires leads to vice; desire sways deliberation.
Augustine Concupiscence, disordered love for earthly goods Enslaved by concupiscence post-Fall Weakened will consents to disordered desires, turning from God.
Aquinas Passions of the soul (movements of appetite) Master of its own acts; can consent to or reject passions Will consents to a disordered passion against reason and divine law.

(Image: A classical oil painting depicting a human figure, perhaps in the style of a Renaissance allegory, torn between two paths or influences. On one side, a figure representing earthly pleasures or immediate gratification beckons with alluring gestures, symbolizing desire. On the other, a more austere, robed figure points upwards or towards a distant, more arduous path, representing reason or virtue. The central figure's face shows a profound internal conflict, with hands reaching out ambivalently, illustrating the will's struggle when confronted by powerful, competing desires that could lead to sin.)

The Mechanism: From Urge to Transgression

The path from an initial desire to a sinful act typically involves several stages:

  1. The Arousal of Desire: An object or idea presents itself, stimulating an internal longing or aversion. This initial stir is often natural and morally neutral.
  2. The Contemplation of Fulfillment: The mind dwells on the desire, imagining its satisfaction. Here, reason begins its engagement, assessing the desire's alignment with moral principles.
  3. The Weakening of Rational Restraint: If the desire is strong and the will is weak or unexercised in virtue, reason's voice can be diminished. The immediate gratification promised by the desire can overshadow long-term consequences or moral imperatives.
  4. The Consent of the Will: This is the critical juncture. The will chooses to act upon the disordered desire, effectively giving its assent to the transgression. This act of choice transforms the internal inclination into a definitive cause of sin.
  5. The Sinful Act: The chosen action is executed, solidifying the sin.

The Enduring Challenge of Desire

The consistent message from the Great Books of the Western World is clear: while desire itself is an inherent aspect of human nature, its proper ordering and governance by reason and a virtuous will are essential for avoiding sin. Whether viewed as an unruly horse, an excessive appetite, or a disordered passion, desire consistently emerges as a powerful antecedent cause that, when unchecked, leads humanity astray from its highest ideals. The ongoing struggle to master one's desires remains a timeless and profoundly human endeavor.

YouTube Video Suggestions:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Plato's Chariot Allegory explained""

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Augustine on Free Will, Evil, and Grace""

Share this post