The Virtue of Tragedy: Exploring the Cathartic Power of Greek Drama

In exploring the purported cathartic power of Greek drama, we must first shed the comforting veil of romanticism and approach this topic with unyielding intellectual rigour. While conventional wisdom suggests that Greek tragedies possess an inherent virtue, offering emotional release and purging the soul, it is essential to challenge these assumptions and critically examine the historical context and effects of such dramatic performances. By meticulously examining Greek drama, we shall reveal catharsis's illusory nature and expose its supposed virtues' limitations.

The Misconception of Catharsis:

To comprehend the origins of the concept of catharsis in Greek drama, we must turn to the writings of Aristotle. Aristotle popularized that tragedy purges or cleanses the soul by arousing and relieving emotions. However, we must be wary of accepting this notion uncritically. Aristotle himself failed to provide a clear definition of catharsis, leaving ample room for interpretation.

The notion of catharsis as emotional release rests on the assumption that viewers of tragedy identify with the characters on stage, experiencing their suffering and ultimately finding relief through resolving their struggles. However, this assumption relies on the fallacy that human emotions are akin to toxins that need purging. Such a view trivializes the complexity and richness of human emotional experiences, reducing them to disturbances requiring expulsion.

Aristotle's Poetics serves as the foundation for our understanding of Greek drama. However, it is crucial to recognize the limitations of this perspective. Aristotle was a product of his time, and his worldview was steeped in the values and norms of ancient Greek society. His vision of tragedy as a means of moral education and emotional release was inherently tied to the broader Greek belief in the existence of an ordered universe governed by divine justice.

The Greek city-states were rife with political strife, warfare, and social inequalities, deeply ingrained in their society's fabric. Greek drama, with its focus on noble characters brought low by tragic flaws or the whims of the gods, offered an outlet for the audience to witness these struggles on stage. However, assuming that such experiences provided genuine catharsis or meaningful moral lessons is erroneous. Instead, the temporary emotional release offered by a tragedy only served as a distraction from the oppressive realities of everyday life, providing momentary respite rather than genuine transformation.

The Commercialization of Tragedy:

To fully grasp the limitations of catharsis, we must examine the commercial aspects of Greek drama. The theatre was a popular form of entertainment, and playwrights catered to the tastes and desires of their audiences. The tragedians' primary goal was not to enlighten or educate but to captivate and entertain. As a result, the demand for spectacle and melodrama often overshadowed any potential for genuine emotional purging or moral reflection.

Moreover, including comedic elements, known as "satyr plays," alongside tragedies further undermines the notion of catharsis. These humorous interludes served as comic relief, diluting any potential cathartic effect that the preceding tragedy might have had. The blending of tragedy and comedy within the same theatrical experience points to a more nuanced and complex understanding of Greek drama that cannot be reduced to a simplistic notion of catharsis.

The Demise of Catharsis:

The decline of Greek drama casts doubt on the supposed cathartic power of tragedy. As the Greek city-states succumbed to external pressures and their political landscape changed, so too did the nature of their theatrical productions. Tragedies gave way to the spectacle of gladiatorial combat and the whimsical performances of mimes. The demise of tragedy suggests that its cathartic function was not as profound or transformative as proponents suggest.

The Modern Interpretation:

While some may argue that catharsis can still be relevant in modern times, it is crucial to recognize that our understanding of the human psyche has evolved. The therapeutic value of drama now lies more in its ability to foster empathy, provoke critical thinking, and illuminate social and psychological complexities. As a result, modern audiences are more likely to seek catharsis through personal introspection, therapy, or engaging with art that challenges their preconceptions rather than relying on the illusion of emotional purging offered by ancient Greek drama.

Conclusion:

In deconstructing the notion of catharsis in Greek drama, we have uncovered a profound illusion perpetuated by centuries of unquestioning acceptance. The supposed virtue of tragedy and its cathartic power crumbles under the weight of historical scrutiny and critical analysis. While Greek drama undoubtedly has intrinsic value as a cultural and artistic phenomenon, we must abandon the notion that it possesses some mystical ability to cleanse the soul. Instead, we should embrace a more nuanced understanding of drama's potential for intellectual engagement, empathy, and exploring the human condition.


Plato Re-Imagined

This course includes 32 lectures covering most of Plato's dialogues and allowing the student to return to something divine. Divinity should resonate with secular and religious leaders alike. I present a compatible approach in my lecture on Consilience.

Also included with this course is a free book. If you pay for the course, you will get a physical copy of the book for free, mailed to your chosen address — anywhere on the planet!

$5 per month (free book)
Share this post