The Problem of Evil: Exploring the Existence of Suffering in a Just World

In the grand theatre of existence, humanity's perennial question is the problem of evil. This inquiry strikes at the heart of our moral sensibilities, demanding an explanation for the coexistence of suffering and an ostensibly just world. But can we genuinely reconcile the existence of immense pain and injustice with the notion of a benevolent and omnipotent deity? In this critical exploration, we shall unveil the fallacy of a just world and expose the insidious nature of suffering that permeates our lives.

The Mirage of Justice:

From the early epochs of human civilization, justice has been heralded as a moral beacon, an ethereal ideal that promises retribution and harmony. Yet, when we survey the annals of history, we are inundated with narratives of suffering and unspeakable atrocities that transcend the bounds of human imagination. If we accept the notion of a just world, we would be compelled to account for the horrors of slavery, the Holocaust, genocides, and countless other manifestations of human cruelty. The evidence is irrefutable: the existence of suffering stands as a monument to the failure of a just world hypothesis.

Divine Absurdity:

To search for meaning in the face of suffering is a natural human inclination. However, to ascribe suffering to the workings of a benevolent deity is to don blinders of ignorance. As a result, the apologist will often resort to convoluted explanations, contending that suffering is a necessary vehicle for spiritual growth or is the consequence of human free will. But such reasoning is nothing more than an intellectual sleight of hand, a desperate attempt to preserve the notion of a benevolent God in the face of overwhelming evidence.

The Weight of History:

When we peel back the layers of history, we find that suffering has long been a companion to humanity, irrespective of our belief systems or moral frameworks. The horrors of the Inquisition, the witch trials, and the Crusades remind us that suffering can thrive in societies dominated by religious fervour. In the darkest recesses of human history, we witness the inextricable link between suffering and the belief in a just world. The dogmas and doctrines propagated by religious institutions have sometimes served as the catalysts for unspeakable acts of violence and human degradation.

The Tyranny of Hope:

One might argue that the existence of suffering is an essential component of our moral journey, as it galvanizes us to seek justice and alleviate the afflictions of others. However, such an argument burdens the victims, demanding that they suffer for the greater good. It is a callous proposition that dismisses the inherent value of individual lives and perpetuates the cycle of suffering under the guise of moral enlightenment. The notion that suffering is necessary for moral progress reeks of intellectual arrogance and a lack of empathy.

The Triumph of Reason:

In our pursuit of truth, we must abandon the comforts of dogma and confront the stark reality of the world. The problem of evil cannot be resolved by clinging to notions of divine justice or the illusory hope of a better tomorrow. We can begin dismantling instead; it is a fortress of suffering through reason, compassion, and a relentless dedication to understanding the human condition. History has shown us that when we divorce ourselves from the shackles of religious delusion, we gain the tools to address suffering in tangible ways, unencumbered by the whims of an absentee deity.

The problem of evil persists as an intellectual battleground, where the clash between faith and reason unfolds. In our pursuit of truth, we must cast aside the comfortable narratives that shield us from the stark reality of suffering. The fallacy of a just world crumbles under the weight of historical atrocities and the palpable anguish experienced by countless individuals. We can navigate the labyrinth of suffering through intellectual rigour, compassion, and a steadfast commitment to human dignity and forge a more just and compassionate world.


Plato Re-Imagined

This course includes 32 lectures covering most of Plato's dialogues and allowing the student to return to something divine. Divinity should resonate with secular and religious leaders alike. I present a compatible approach in my lecture on Consilience.

Also included with this course is a free book. If you pay for the course, you will get a physical copy of the book for free, mailed to your chosen address — anywhere on the planet!

$5 per month (free book)
Share this post