The Ethics of Influencer Marketing: Authenticity and Disclosure

In the digital age of consumerism, where the relentless pursuit of profit reigns supreme, influencer marketing has emerged as a powerful tool for shaping public opinion and purchasing decisions. However, beneath the carefully crafted veneer of authenticity and relatability lies a web of ethical problems that demand critical scrutiny. This article delves deep into the ethics of influencer marketing, unravelling the complexities of authenticity and disclosure while questioning the foundations upon which this marketing strategy is built.

The Charade of Authenticity:

At the heart of influencer marketing lies authenticity, which is purportedly indispensable for establishing trust between influencers and their audience. Yet, in an era where image manipulation reigns supreme, can we genuinely equate authenticity with an influencer's carefully curated online persona? Influencers meticulously construct their public identities, filtering their lives through a lens of glamorous idealism. The result is a distorted representation of reality, where envy-inducing content is artfully presented as an authentic portrayal of everyday life. Instead, it is a mirage, skillfully crafted to ignite desire and drive consumerism.

Historically, authenticity has been associated with objective truths and genuine experiences. Søren Kierkegaard, the eminent Danish philosopher, posited that genuine authenticity lies in the individual's willingness to embrace their unique self and grapple with existential questions. In contrast, the influencer's relentless quest for popularity and profit appears antithetical to the pursuit of genuine authenticity. In their carefully curated narratives, the individual becomes a commodity, and pursuing commercial success replaces seeking truth.

The Deceptive Art of Disclosure:

A crucial aspect of ethical marketing is transparency; the disclosure issue looms large in influencer marketing. Disclosure requirements aim to safeguard the consumer's right to make informed decisions. Unfortunately, however, the current state of disclosure practices is woefully inadequate, with ambiguities and evasive tactics employed by influencers and brands alike.

Disclosures are often buried in a sea of hashtags or relegated to obscure corners of a post, diminishing their impact and relevance. In this game of deception, the influencer becomes complicit in blurring the lines between genuine endorsement and covert advertising. By cloaking paid partnerships within a facade of personal recommendations, influencers betray the trust of their followers, eroding the authenticity they claim to embody.

A historical parallel can be drawn here. In the early 20th century, Edward Bernays, the "father of public relations," astutely recognized the power of manipulating public opinion through subtle persuasion. Bernays, who famously used his uncle Sigmund Freud's psychoanalytical insights to engineer consent, would have marvelled at the exploitative potential of influencer marketing. Like Bernays' public relations campaigns, influencer marketing thrives on subtly influencing consumer behaviour without triggering skepticism or resistance.

A Call for Intellectual Vigilance:

To address the ethical quandaries of influencer marketing, we must challenge conventional wisdom and demand greater accountability from influencers and the brands they promote. Regulatory bodies must establish stringent guidelines prioritizing transparency and holding influencers and brands accountable for their actions. Unambiguous disclosure practices, devoid of the current obfuscation tactics, are a necessary first step toward restoring authenticity to the influencer landscape.

Moreover, consumers themselves bear a crucial responsibility. As active participants in the marketplace, consumers should exercise intellectual vigilance, questioning the authenticity of influencer narratives and critically evaluating the motives behind the content they consume. By actively seeking genuine and diverse perspectives, consumers can resist the allure of commercial manipulation and shape a more authentic and responsible digital culture.


In influencer marketing, the pursuit of profit often trumps authenticity and transparency. This article has critically engaged with the ethical dimensions of influencer marketing, exposing the illusory nature of authenticity and the deceptive practices surrounding disclosure. By drawing upon historical insights and challenging conventional wisdom, we have told the underbelly of this marketing strategy, urging society to embrace intellectual rigour and demand a more authentic and ethically responsible digital landscape. Only through collective action and unwavering academic scrutiny can we hope to break free from the chains of manipulation and reclaim the integrity of human connection in the age of consumerism.

Plato Re-Imagined

This course includes 32 lectures covering most of Plato's dialogues and allowing the student to return to something divine. Divinity should resonate with secular and religious leaders alike. I present a compatible approach in my lecture on Consilience.

Also included with this course is a free book. If you pay for the course, you will get a physical copy of the book for free, mailed to your chosen address — anywhere on the planet!

$5 per month (free book)
Share this post