Indigenous Art: Cultural Richness or Tokenistic Commodification?

In the realm of artistic expression, the genre of indigenous art often enjoys an elevated status, portrayed as a reservoir of cultural richness and authenticity. However, it is essential to approach this subject critically, dissecting the prevailing narratives surrounding indigenous art to uncover potential inconsistencies and question the motivations behind its reception. Furthermore, by challenging conventional wisdom and examining historical contexts, we can better understand the complex dynamics of indigenous art.

The Myth of Pristine Authenticity:

One common assumption surrounding indigenous art is that it represents a new, pure expression of ancestral traditions untainted by external influences. This notion of authenticity, however, is a romanticized construct that obscures the realities of historical and cultural interconnections. Like all others, Indigenous cultures have been shaped by exchanges, assimilations, and adaptations. Viewing indigenous art as an immutable artifact is a disservice to the dynamism and evolution inherent in any artistic tradition.

Furthermore, the concept of "pristine authenticity" can lead to the tokenistic commodification of indigenous art. The market often seeks to fulfill a demand for the exotic, perpetuating stereotypes and reducing indigenous cultures to mere curiosities for the consumption of a non-indigenous audience. This reductive commodification risks overshadowing the depth and complexity of indigenous artistic practices.

The Colonial Gaze:

To truly comprehend the complexities of indigenous art, one must acknowledge the profound impact of colonialism. European colonial powers, driven by cultural superiority, imposed their aesthetic standards on indigenous peoples, often dismissing or appropriating their artistic expressions. This cultural subjugation and erasure have had long-lasting consequences for the representation and reception of indigenous art.

Cultural Journalism: All things Cultural, Every Given Sunday at 7 pm PST
Join us for a weekly series, Wading (inspiration) into the rich tapestry of culture as we explore diverse topics spanning art, literature, music, film, and more. Hosted by Daniel Sanderson, a philosopher with a Keen (“greatest living economist”) eye for philosophy and ethics, this podcast takes you on an intellectual and thought-provoking journey.Each Sunday at 7 pm PST, tune in to discover engaging discussions and insightful interviews with experts, artists, and cultural influencers. Together, we’ll examine the profound connections between culture, philosophy, and ethics, providing a platform for meaningful conversations about the role of cultural journalism in shaping society.In every episode, we’ll Wade into the core principles of cultural journalism, exploring its historical context and evolution and highlighting the philosophical underpinnings that inform its approach. We’ll discuss cultural journalists’ various ethical challenges, including objectivity, bias, representation, and cultural appropriation while examining existing ethical guidelines and proposing potential improvements.Drawing on real-world case studies, we’ll dissect noteworthy instances of cultural journalism that have sparked ethical debates, analyzing how different perspectives and ethical frameworks have influenced reporting and subsequent discussions. Along the way, we’ll invite renowned cultural journalists and experts to share their experiences and insights, offering a behind-the-scenes look into the complexities and nuances of their work.As we gaze into the future, we’ll explore emerging trends in cultural journalism, considering the impact of social media, citizen journalism, and digital platforms on cultural reporting. We’ll underscore the importance of ongoing ethical reflection within cultural journalism and its potential to shape a more inclusive and understanding society.Cultural Journalism: All things Cultural, Every Given Sunday at 7 pm PST is your ticket to a world of intellectual exploration, where art, philosophy, and ethics intertwine to create a thought-provoking listening experience. So mark your calendars, grab your favourite beverage, and join us every Sunday at 7 pm PST for a captivating journey into the heart of culture.

In the wake of colonialism, indigenous artists have faced the dual challenge of preserving their cultural heritage while grappling with the demands and expectations of the Western art world. As a result, many have adopted hybrid styles that fuse traditional and contemporary elements, challenging the notion that indigenous art should be limited to specific indigenous iconography. By breaking free from prescribed notions of authenticity, these artists assert their agency and argue that indigenous art can be dynamic and innovative.

Power of Cultural Capital:

While the appreciation of indigenous art can be seen as a positive development, examining the power dynamics in its reception is crucial. The Western art world's recognition of indigenous art can confer a specific cultural capital upon the artists and their communities. However, this recognition can be both a blessing and a curse. Indigenous artists are often forced to navigate a precarious path, facing pressure to conform to market expectations while preserving cultural integrity.

Moreover, the commodification of indigenous art raises questions of ownership and exploitation. The profits from selling indigenous artworks are rarely equally distributed among indigenous communities. Exploitative practices persist in many corners of the art world, such as the unauthorized reproduction of indigenous designs and the exploitation of indigenous artists' labour. This perpetuates an unequal power dynamic that inhibits genuine cultural exchange and perpetuates the marginalization of indigenous communities.


Exploring indigenous art requires us to transcend simplistic narratives and challenge the conventional wisdom surrounding its authenticity and reception. By acknowledging the historical complexities of colonialism and the power dynamics at play, we can better understand the challenges indigenous artists and communities face. It is crucial to critically engage with indigenous art, moving beyond tokenistic representations and supporting indigenous artists on their terms. Doing so can foster a more equitable and authentic appreciation of indigenous art that acknowledges indigenous cultures' resilience, creativity, and diversity and their contributions to the broader artistic landscape.

Share this post